At Hendrickson we have the percussion students play both in Pit and on the Drumline.
Granted we might have the more talened students playing the marimba's and less talented on the Rack but all the parts in the pit are complicated. Then there is the switch to the drumline in our 4th movement. All the keyboard players switch to Battery leaving a just a few still in the pit set up to play the drumset and rack, ect.
For the past three years I've been on the drumline and then I am put on a vibe part in this years show and I never really knew how much the pit had to do. The setting up, the pushing, the warm-ups, the 80million runs we have to learn. A lot of the other drummers in my band are realizing that as well since now WE ALL have to do it. I can't really say the pit is where the 'un-talented' kids go because you really have to focus on and learn a lot. I am not saying the drumline doesn't. What I honestly think, it's two different worlds. This year some of the more talented pit players are having to march a drum. And they are turning out to being really talented drum players. Also they are learning the difficulties of marching and learning notes and guiding and watching the drum majors as well.
My point is,
Everyone can be well-rounded if given the chance.
No one can be deemed un-talented just by the drum or keyboard they are placed on.