brahmsbxch

Yeah I’m so sorry but Poteet should have not gone through, no less place 2nd. Even if their music performance was the at much improved, their marching is incredibly dirty. And this is someone who loves the pirate band and wants to be objective.

It’s not a stretch lol that’s an objective measure. And even if their winds have music that’s on par difficulty (which they don’t), you just conceded that their percussion book (which is considered with the whole difficulty) isn’t as difficult, so it follows that as a whole Kaufman’s music book isn’t as difficult. It’s not a value judgement just a fact. Good on them, though, because it’s seems to pay off to balance that with being really clean. On the flip side, part of Poteet’s struggle is that their music is seeming to be a bit of a challenge and hindering their ability to get their show clean.

Haven’t seen them in person, but they are just really clean. Their music book is not as difficult as Mt. P, NM, WM, Poteet, HP or even LC. what are your predictions based off what you saw?

“the kids seem to really enjoy it and get to be Egyptian” is crazy 😂 That only underscores my point. Let’s just have shows where kids can have fun being Indian or Chinese or Nigerian! The whole premise is just not cool, especially when certain groups are targets of discrimination and can’t just choose not to be part of that group if they want. It’s insensitive and I can bet on the fact that Kaufman has no Middle Eastern students to even say it’s celebrating. And even if it was true, playing “walk like an Egyptian” is not a celebration of Egyptian culture. This isn’t even me being sensitive, I’m just perplexed at the lack of acknowledgement about how the show is not respectful or the fact that there are SOOO many more options.

I honestly think it’s going to be really tight. I think North and Kaufman (even though I’m a Kaufman hater bc of the subject matter of their show) will make it. That third spot is a toss up; It can be WM, LC, Poteet or HP. I feel insane to not put Poteet as a shoe in but they are just nowhere near clean and their competition results reflect that (especially given the rumor that WM ranked higher at MMF). Something no one has brought up is the fact that all these schools have a fall break this week—I wonder if that will stall progress and meaningfully effect outcomes at Area. An early takeaway from this season is that this Area actually is competitive. Additionally, it’s notable how West Mesquite has improved so much that they are (allegedly) beating Poteet, and winning competitions and percussion contests, and in consideration by people in this forum for state. Forney’s departure in fact did not leave a void for interest in this Area.

We should probably expect only 3 spots for state and would be lucky to get 4. 5 is just out of the realm of possibility because a lot of bands in this area from DISD historically get 2s (even 3s) at region.

Yeah. I think there’s an argument that there’s a battle for both the 3rd and 4th spots between 5 bands. I appreciate the unexpected competitiveness of this area this year.

Red oak is not doing as well as other years either https://youtu.be/yGlOhWALD2A?si=3PvHa3vNahyRQwP2

Based off of today’s comps and the season thus far : 1. North Mesquite 2. Kaufman 3. West Mesquite 4. Poteet / HP Mt Pleasant Lakeview Centennial Terrell Red Oak Texas

Anyone have the prelims and finals results for this comp?