I watched all the prelims and finals shows... (boy, was my bottom sore from sitting all day!)
I used a simple way to rate and rank the prelims performances: Division 1, 2, 3 etc. except I added -, --, +, ++ to each divisional rating which allows for 5 degrees within each division. I placed music ahead of marching in determining order. If there was a tie, I simple picked the show and performance I preferred.
Here are my prelim results along with judges' outcome:
School Music Marching My Order J Order Finals Result
Marcus 1++ 1++ 1 1 Yes State
LD Bell 1++ 1++ 2 2 Yes State
Plano 1++ 1+ 3 20
Mansfield 1++ 1+ 4 18
Summit 1++ 1 5 7 Yes Alternate
Richland 1+ 1++ 6 4 Yes State
Hebron 1+ 1+ 7 5 Yes State
N Smith 1+ 1+ 8 10 Yes Alternate
Tmbrvw 1+ 1+ 9 17
Haltom 1+ 1+ 10 3 Yes State
Allen 1+ 1 11 9 Yes No
Lewisville 1+ 1- 12 11
Cllyvll Hrtg 1 1+ 13 15
Wylie 1 1+ 14 13
Plano East 1 1 15 6 Yes No
Flwr Mnd 1 1 16 12
Creekview 1- 1+ 17 8 Yes No
Paschal 1- 1+ 18 23
Martin 1- 1+ 19 14
Carroll 1-- 1 20 16
N Crowley 1-- 1- 21 21
Plano West 1-- 2 22 25
Granbury 2++ 1 23 29
Grapevine 2+ 1 24 19
Arlington 2+ 1- 25 26
Bowie 2+ 1- 26 22
Lamar 2+ 2+ 27 24
Burleson 2 2 28 28
RL Turner 2-- 2-- 29 27
This system was surprisingly close to the judges outcome with a few glaring exceptions. Plano, Mansfield and Timberview didn't make finals. Notice however, the 3 bands I didn't pick for finals (Allen, Plano East, Creekview) were the only 3 finalists that didn't advanced to state or didn't get picked as alternates.... hmmm.
My picks:
Best Musical Performance - Marcus (prelims & finals)
Best Marching Performance - LD Bell (finals)
Favorite Show - LD Bell
Favorite Music - N Smith
Funnest Show - Marcus
Most Powerful and Impressive Sound - Allen (how do they attack, release and articulate so cleanly?) This is the first time I truely enjoyed this musical book performed by any band or drum corps. Congrats!
Great Guards - Richland, LD Bell, Creekview. (sorry if I left anyone out, I was not meticulous making notes about the guards.)
Some criticize Marcus' show as being gimmicky... I usually hate props, but everything they do enhances their show. Marching is not challenging at all (not a negative comment) compared to their closest competitors, but extremely polished...perfect to be precise. This allows them to easily be head and shoulders above the rest in music. Very challenging music played with perfect tone, intonation and balance. Great dynamics and nuance. [LOL!! Thanks for the edit heads up, Xenon.] And, LOTS OF FUN TO BOOT! Awesome soloists! Prelims and finals were equally consistent and well performed.
LD Bell's prelims performance lacked the polish one expects from them; however, there finals performance was intense and smokin'. This show and performance will score much higher at BOA SA and GN. I like the new uniform, but the dark pants do not highlight the frenetic marching that this talented unit displays. Much more impressive marching "look" at BOA Arlington in light colored pants. I really like the new tops and VERY WHITE shako and tall plum. The whole unit now looks very TALL and much trimmer.
Plano East and Creekview really turned in great finals performances which in my mind validated their presence in finals. I really got into their shows! Lots of energy and emotion! Great jobs! Richland's finals performance was head and shoulders more intense and emotional and flat out better than their prelims effort. Congrats!
I thoroughly enjoyed all the shows and appreciate all the hard work that went into them. Thank you for giving me the privilege to witness this wonderful spectacle.
UP! DOWN! LEFT! RIGHT! (Anyone know what show this is from?)
Everyone get ready for STATE!!