This one is so hard to predict, but here we go:
Finalists (Panel):
Vandegrift (1)
Marcus(1)
TWHS (1)
FloMo(1)
Pearland(1)
Cedar Park (2)
Rouse (2)
Vista Ridge (2)
Hebron (2)
Westlake (2) - more on them later
Coppell (1-next 4)
Reagan (1-next 4)
Cedar Ridge (1-next 4)
Bowie (1-next 4)
Who Gets Left Out (among others)
Round Rock (1)
Waxahachie (2)
Leander (2)
CTJ (2)
Keller (2)
LD Bell (2)
Southlake (2)
MG Johnson (2)
I think there are nine bands on Panel 1 that stand out as clear finalists. This is the most lopsided seeding we've ever seen at the Super Regional. It might just be luck of the draw, but it really puts the Panel 2 bands at a disadvantage. While it might seem unlikely for all four "next highest scores" to come from the same panel, I just can't see any of those groups being left out.
Panel 2 is harder to predict, but even then, the first four bands I listed are almost guaranteed finalists. I chose Westlake as my last "top five" band in Panel 2 because their GE scores at BOA Waco were higher than anyone's except CR. Since GE is weighted so heavily, that gave them the edge for me. Plus, Westlake consistently marches and plays at a high level year in and year out.
It was tough to leave Round Rock out of the finals because I think their show is solid and will continue to improve through the State Marching Band Contest. If they were in Panel 2, they’d have a strong case to make finals over Westlake.
Leander and Southlake also have entertaining shows, but I don't see them overtaking Westlake for that last spot in Panel 2. CTJ has been middle of the pack at their two regionals, so I’m curious to see how much they’ve grown since then. If they’re hitting their stride, they could sneak into that final Panel 2 spot. Waxahachie plays incredibly well but is still trying to get their GE to match.
Keller has been a finalist here every year since 2015, with one of the best brass sections in the country during that run. However, based on the videos I’ve seen, they don’t seem to have the same sound quality or difficulty in their wind writing as other finalists. Their guard has also had lower scores at their first two shows, which has historically been a major factor at BOASA.
The same goes for LD Bell. While their guard is still fantastic, their show isn’t hitting the GE benchmarks like past productions. There’s potential for growth, but at this stage in the season, it may be tough for them to secure a finalist spot.
There's a 100% chance that I'm wrong, but all of this is just for fun anyway. The only thing that is for sure is that there will be a lot of great performances by a lot of great bands!