This is exactly the reason why as a student of a program it's best to not try to over-analyse the judges sheet. As a student YOU ARE BIASED, and with reason, you feel an emotional connection to your program because only you know exactly how much work you put into a show and the experiences you've had with these people. Even as a recent graduate I still have this biased towards my ala mater, I still feel emotionally invested in the program, and it clouds the judging mind. It's expected missing out on something like state sucks, or not getting what you would expect at any competition, once it's ended and you've had time to cool down take a second and think. The is art and is opinionated. If you're in this activity at all I'm sure your doing it for the experience not just some simple win, if you want that you might as well do a more simple activity that doesn't consume as much time or money. "Bad" judging will probably happen more then once in you high school career. You aren't going to be talking about what Judge 4 gave you in marching in 10 yrs(I hope not), but will remember what an amazing high school experiance you had because of the activity.
My most memorable show happened my senior year where after our finals performance, what we felt had the most energy and emotion yet, knocked us down 2 places. But I honestly DIDN'T CARE, I could only think about the importance of the past four years and the tears of joy in my face.
And on another note after watching my video a couple times after, it was full of energy but not nearly as clean as prelims lol.
And for my last tangent. If you are going to use forums like these to chat try not to stir things up, no talking about how wrong the judges were for placing your school low or how so-and-so school doesn't sound anywhere as good as you. Regardless of if you think it is true or not, YOU ARE BIASED. At the very least if you are going to be provocative make sure you leave you school name out as too not make them look bad lamo.