2024 BOA San Antonio Super Regional (Nov. 8 & 9)

[qwertytb12]

Just now, cheeto2401 said:

i think flomo might take the dub

It might happen, but im going with hebron, cant wait to say I told you so at the end

[cheeto2401]

Just now, qwertytb12 said:

Ok but like judges can make scores however high or low, thats why you cant cross scores over contests or years.

are we ranking this like how it sounded from a judges perspective or a audience members perspective

[cheeto2401]

Just now, qwertytb12 said:

It might happen, but im going with hebron, cant wait to say I told you so at the end

brother 💀

[JoeSchmoe]

2 minutes ago, cheeto2401 said:

their 2022 show was almost a point higher than penstriped at the same contest (san antonio super regional)

Scores don’t mean anything from different years or contests. I’m sure 2022 Hebron would’ve been beat clean by 2021 Hebron. 

[RPBGlazer]

Personally, Its a tossup between The Woodlands, Hebron, and Flomo for me, but I’m leaning towards The Woodlands

[JoeSchmoe]

Just now, RPBGlazer said:

Personally, Its a tossup between The Woodlands, Hebron, and Flomo for me, but I’m leaning towards The Woodlands

The Woodlands is the only thing that makes sense, because I do not know who the audience is rooting for. They seem confused cause they have no clue who’s going to win. Lets just give it to Pearland TBH

[John McKinsleigh]

Who are these people???????

[CPGuardDad]

Marcus' show should come with a seizure warning! This was my first time seeing it, and it's one of my favorites this year. 

[Tubalord11]

34 minutes ago, BandMama82 said:

Did you purposely skip over Keller Central Friday night? I mean I know it was late and all but still 😂

I had band rehearsal that evening and was only able to watch the first two blocks of prelims, sorry 

[qwertytb12]

6 minutes ago, cheeto2401 said:

are we ranking this like how it sounded from a judges perspective or a audience members perspective

I mean ig audience but scores can change over time so I stand with my intial argument, if the winning band today scores higher then penstriped or whatever their show was in 22, will you call it better then that show or every show that it has beat, probably not

[Tubalord11]

Beautiful performance from Marcus to close out finals!!! Still sounding like a concert band, such a big and bright sound from the ensemble. Lovely soloists throughout, and gosh that drumline was insane, imo the best of the night. Visually a little lose at times, but still some really great moments, love the music writing so much though, and their execution of it is at such a high level, wonderful job Marcus!! 

[MarchingMafia]

Oh dear, Marcus, I am breathless. That sustained part is incredible. I keep waiting for you to breathe and you don't.

I don't even know what to say. You're clean. You're precise. You're beautiful.

Just what I was hoping for. Thank you 

[cheeto2401]

here's this if ya'll needed it

[cheeto2401]

friendly reminder that i will be doing my own scoreboard here!! there prolly will be multiple but im letting yall know that im gonna be one of the many people who announce scores

[tubapop]

Rooting for Vista Ridge, Woodlands, and Flomo in that order. I didn’t feel Hebron and definitely didn’t feel vandegrift. 

[lost]

Results (if we only judged shows based on organs)

 

1. Rouse

2. Coppell

[JoeSchmoe]

3 minutes ago, qwertytb12 said:

I mean ig audience but scores can change over time so I stand with my intial argument, if the winning band today scores higher then penstriped or whatever their show was in 22, will you call it better then that show or every show that it has beat, probably not

No, if some bands get higher than penstriped 2021, it’s just a score inflation. That show is unmatched 

[cheeto2401]

1 minute ago, lost said:

Results (if we only judged shows based on organs)

 

1. Rouse

2. Coppell

Results (if we only judges the shows that's an LISD school)

1. Hebron

2. FloMo

3. Vandegrift

4. Marcus

5. Rouse

6. Cedar Park

7. Vista Ridge

 

[Tubalord11]

Alrighty everyone, with the conclusion of finals, here is my BIG guess at finals. Keep in mind this is based of Box5, so I don’t have the same experience as being in person. I think a LOT of these spots are interchangeable,

1. Hebron 

2. Flower Mound 

3. Vandegrift 

4. Marcus 

5. Vista Ridge 

6. Rouse 

7. The Woodlands 

8. Pearland 

9. Ronald Reagan 

10. Cedar Ridge 

11. McNeil 

12. Cedar Park 

13. Coppell 

14. Round Rock 

15. Seven Lakes 

 Music: Hebron 

Visual: Flower Mound

GE: Hebron or Flomo 

[qwertytb12]

4 minutes ago, JoJoWithTheBowBow said:

No, if some bands get higher than penstriped 2021, it’s just a score inflation. That show is unmatched 

Thats literally what ive been saying this whole time, penstriped is best, everything else is just change over time, because change is everything(Only some will get it)

[qwertytb12]

1 minute ago, Tubalord11 said:

Alrighty everyone, with the conclusion of finals, here is my BIG guess at finals. Keep in mind this is based of Box5, so I don’t have the same experience as being in person. I think a LOT of these spots are interchangeable,

1. Hebron 

2. Flower Mound 

3. Vandegrift 

4. Marcus 

5. Vista Ridge 

6. Rouse 

7. The Woodlands 

8. Pearland 

9. Ronald Reagan 

10. Cedar Ridge 

11. McNeil 

12. Cedar Park 

13. Coppell 

14. Round Rock 

15. Seven Lakes 

 Music: Hebron 

Visual: Flower Mound

GE: Hebron or Flomo 

1. Hebron 

2. Flower Mound 

3. Vandegrift 

4. Marcus 

5. Vista Ridge 

6. The Woodlands

7. Rouse

8. Ronald Reagan 

9. Pearland

10. Cedar Ridge 

11. Cedar Park

12. Round Rock

13. Coppell 

14. Mcneil

15. Seven Lakes

[JoeSchmoe]

2 minutes ago, Tubalord11 said:

Alrighty everyone, with the conclusion of finals, here is my BIG guess at finals. Keep in mind this is based of Box5, so I don’t have the same experience as being in person. I think a LOT of these spots are interchangeable,

1. Hebron 

2. Flower Mound 

3. Vandegrift 

4. Marcus 

5. Vista Ridge 

6. Rouse 

7. The Woodlands 

8. Pearland 

9. Ronald Reagan 

10. Cedar Ridge 

11. McNeil 

12. Cedar Park 

13. Coppell 

14. Round Rock 

15. Seven Lakes 

 Music: Hebron 

Visual: Flower Mound

GE: Hebron or Flomo 

Aw man, the bias is obvious 😭😭

[MikeKyu]

Retreat is delayed. The more people post their predictions the more the judges have to change their scores to get a true sense of GE. Or maybe the judges are just having Box 5 stuttering issues on their stream and we are all living in the future as they tabulate true GE (which should be 95% of the score) from the forums. 

[cheeto2401]

1 minute ago, JoJoWithTheBowBow said:

Aw man, the bias is obvious 😭😭

me trying to find the bias

[cheeto2401]

Just now, MikeKyu said:

Retreat is delayed. The more people post their predictions the more the judges have to change their scores to get a true sense of GE. Or maybe the judges are just having Box 5 stuttering issues on their stream and we are all living in the future as they tabulate true GE (which should be 95% of the score) from the forums. 

are boa judges seriously looking at txbands rn