Jump to content

UIL 6A Area E 2024

Online Marcher
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 505
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

MadHornist
MadHornist

Region 17 just wrapped up the regional marching competition with all 6A schools qualifying for the Area E marching competition.  Good luck to all bands, moving forward!

TheSV-001Gamer
TheSV-001Gamer

Not enough sam rayburn high school in any of these lists. Like how you gonna leave the school who went to state in 1980-1983 4 times consecutively. Like they still got that dawg in them and could beat

UIL
UIL

Hey guys it’s me UIL good luck Saturday 👍

Posted Images

  • Popular Post
TheSV-001Gamer Collaborator

TheSV-001Gamer

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted
  On 11/3/2024 at 6:10 PM, GlitterGirly said:

Esp the visual 1 judge D. Brandon his scores we’re literally all over the place and also i’m pretty sure these judges were biased because they came from the districts of bands that were there and their bands went to finals shocker right? I get those bands are good but Pasadena Memorial was screwed for prelims but they had a judge from their district and they made finals when they definitely didn’t do the best. I’m just saying UIL did not pick the best judges for this event.

Expand  

Untrue, no judges were from the Houston area or Pasadena ISD. If they were truly biased towards Pasadena Memorial they would of been placed higher. The judges were all from the Dallas Austin Area 

From my understanding you are misunderstanding how Freedom Field before finals announcements, announced the representatives from several districts not just Pasadena ISD. NOT the judges 

If this were the case other schools in Pasadena ISD would of been placed higher. 

And you can't deny that Pasadena Memorial had consistent judging in Finals that put them over bands like Clements, Fulshear, and Foster.

If they didn't deserve it they would of placed 10th in finals.

The prelims judging was wacky I do understand that.

 

  • Popular Post
a center marimba Newbie

a center marimba

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted
  On 11/3/2024 at 6:10 PM, GlitterGirly said:

Esp the visual 1 judge D. Brandon his scores we’re literally all over the place and also i’m pretty sure these judges were biased because they came from the districts of bands that were there and their bands went to finals shocker right? I get those bands are good but Pasadena Memorial was screwed for prelims but they had a judge from their district and they made finals when they definitely didn’t do the best. I’m just saying UIL did not pick the best judges for this event.

Expand  

I would definitely go and do some research on the judges who judged at this event before posting something like this….

GlitterGirly Rookie

GlitterGirly

Posted
Posted
  On 11/3/2024 at 6:20 PM, TheSV-001Gamer said:

Untrue, no judges were from the Houston area or Pasadena ISD. If they were truly biased towards Pasadena Memorial they would of been placed higher. The judges were all from the Dallas Austin Area 

From my understanding you are misunderstanding how Freedom Field before finals announcements, announced the representatives from several districts not just Pasadena ISD. NOT the judges 

If this were the case other schools in Pasadena ISD would of been placed higher. 

And you can't deny that Pasadena Memorial had consistent judging in Finals that put them over bands like Clements, Fulshear, and Foster.

If they didn't deserve it they would of placed 10th in finals.

The prelims judging was wacky I do understand that.

 

Expand  

I was not trying to down them in finals but i did think they were screwed in prelims due to the rain and weather during their performance and thank you for correcting me that was my mistake and prelims was wacky

TheSV-001Gamer Collaborator

TheSV-001Gamer

Posted
Posted
  On 11/3/2024 at 6:30 PM, GlitterGirly said:

I was not trying to down them in finals but i did think they were screwed in prelims due to the rain and weather during their performance and thank you for correcting me that was my mistake and prelims was wacky

Expand  

You're right, weather definitely had a factor.

Also it didn't rain while Pasadena Memorial performed when I saw their prelims run in youtube.

It can truly account to what happened yesterday, it is surprising seeing the consistency of where bands stand throughout the season just for Area to mix everything up like never before

UIL judging is interesting and created the product of yesterday, at the end of the day that's what some bands do really well, at appealing to the scoring system and others don't. 

UIL is about clean clean clean, musically and visually, and that's what we saw. 

Why do you think Hebron lost to Vandy 2022 state finals, Vandy just had a cleaner run. Even though hebron had an overall outstanding show.

But yeah prelims was interesting. Like bwood to 24th 🤯 after 6th in finals last year ??

Yacob Apprentice

Yacob

Posted
Posted

The top 5 spots were wack.

 

we knew Pearland was going to get 1st.

Dawson I have to say has a better show than Clear Brook and Dickinson.

i feel like the score between CB and Dickinson was very close. 
 

and I haven’t seen SFAs show so I have no comment on them.

Valentina Newbie

Valentina

Posted
Posted

Once again travis member here I know we made 14th but im in guard so if anyone saw our show and could tell me where the major points taken off were it would help alot! I know we got 2 penalites but I just wanted to know the other reasons!

TubaBuke Contributor

TubaBuke

Posted
Posted
  On 11/3/2024 at 6:38 AM, TheSV-001Gamer said:

At the same time the judging was ok, like the finals looked sorta consistent, but there were bands riddled with like a 5 from one judge 

The prelims judging is straight up crazy bro Deer Park over Clear Falls is insane work 

Other examples like that follow, 

Expand  

I was really shocked to see Clear Springs over some of the other groups as well as Deer Park. But regardless, I hope kids had runs they felt proud of and grew as musicians and people too with all the hard work. Onto concert season and whoever has indoor perc and guard programs, which I am very excited for this upcoming season.

  • Popular Post
MadHornist Enthusiast

MadHornist

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted
  On 11/3/2024 at 7:06 PM, Texanhotshot said:

Foster and Fulshear did absolutely amazing, they definitely got robbed in my opinion. While I get UIL is about cleanliness, seems to be huge bias on the bigger bands for being just that, big. 

Expand  

I rewatched their shows.  They both have the size and talent to be more competitive.  The only thing that I observed was that the musical scoring of their shows sounded easier than what was played by some of the higher scoring bands. That is definitely something that is easier to address than the physical band size, which is what holds back many other quality programs.

  • Popular Post
Oboeish20 Enthusiast

Oboeish20

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted

My thoughts (IMO)

Foster and Fulshear moved up to 6A, it’s a different class and game entirely. We probably shouldn’t have had any expectations. They did well in context of that.

I honestly think judging was pretty well done here, many of the groups saw consistent Neighborhood numbers which is good. This is a lot different than pre-2022 when everything was all over the place. I think the folks at UIL are to be commended.

Also, the venue was AMAZING.

TubaBuke Contributor

TubaBuke

Posted
Posted
  On 11/3/2024 at 10:26 PM, Pulse said:

I’m surprised shadow creek didn’t make finals does anyone have an idea why that visual judge ranked them so low?

Expand  

Ig just the judge thought so 🤷‍♂️ tbh can't really describe why from their pov it wasn't like they were dirty visually so not sure tbh.

TheSV-001Gamer Collaborator

TheSV-001Gamer

Posted
Posted
  On 11/3/2024 at 10:03 PM, TubaBuke said:

Do yall think there is ever a chance area E gets split up again in a couple years like years ago when there was so many groups?

Expand  

I think that would happen if the Area got too large like Area C, or competitive.

But it seems pretty organized rn, there's no need for the area to be split up again.

  • Popular Post
lizzard2027 Apprentice

lizzard2027

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted

Can we take just a minute to focus on all the cool and unique show ideas? 

I'm gonna say Sam Rayburn had such a cool idea with the Medusa theme, and I loved how they literally carried the flutist off the field after she "got turned to stone". 🐍

Clear Brook also spinning the band kid inside the prop was so cool! :) 

Tianlong (Idk which school) was so cool! I loved the little dragon bridges, but it would have been SOOO cool to have a dragon head stage for soloists to stand on (that would probably cost a fortune tho :D)

I didn't understand Pearland's show (especially the circle things at the end) so can someone enlighten me? From what I figured, it has some sort of Greek theme. In any case, 14 sousaphones is crazy work, and a 50 person guard (maybe 40 or 60, I'm not good at counting) is actually crazy 😮 

Loved Cloud 9 from Ridgepoint! Such a cool theme, and the guard members are so nice 🥰

All in all, so many bands getting slept on because they weren't finalists or in the finalist bubble :(  (not taking the finalists down or saying these bands should've made finals, just want to appreciate all the show ideas!)

Congrats to all the state bands btw! (Loved the slides in Dawson's show!)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...