UIL 5A State Marching Contest 2024 (Nov. 4-5)

[BariSaxyGuy]

I see predictions and the top 6 all make sense, but I have seen some that have BC and CH in the finals but I don't see Midlo. I have seen both shows and they beat both at area and beat CH in prelims of the Mansfield POC and was barely behind BC at BOA Waco. I know its a very close race but what are yalls thoughts? 

[WanderingTraveler]

  On 10/30/2024 at 6:21 PM, BariSaxyGuy said:

I see predictions and the top 6 all make sense, but I have seen some that have BC and CH in the finals but I don't see Midlo. I have seen both shows and they beat both at area and beat CH in prelims of the Mansfield POC and was barely behind BC at BOA Waco. I know its a very close race but what are yalls thoughts? 

Expand  

I see the reasoning for this to be 2 fold...1. History of what the trend has been in the past few years (for those that haven't seen all the bands this year) and 2. Some seasoned programs will have been through this rodeo before, making them have a slight advantage.

I have been around the marching scene for a while now (went to a 5A school), but when I make my 4A predictions, I am basing on results from the year as well as the trends from the past...Such as systematically, North Lamar has a long standing trend of success, so even if there was an upcoming band that could easily dethrone them, I wouldn't be as aware of it until the actual day of the contest comes. Similarly, if memory serves me correctly, different competitions have had different outcomes between the three BC, Midlothian, and CH (despite some being BOA style). So some of these instances I predict looking at the big picture. Even prelims and finals area Area F had them ranked in a different order.

Also, when I mention program history, some people have honestly just been to state more, so they have experience in how to handle the whole process. This is the same reason you will see Argyle placed above McKinney North in most peoples predictions (although McKinney North beat them in both prelims and finals at Area B.). This is because they dominated in 4A SMBC before being moved up to 5A, so they have a ton of experience in that regard.

All 3 of these Area F bands are super talented, and honestly, as I have said in another thread, will probably come down to the runs and the judges preferences.

Predictions are hard, and almost never fully accurate, which is why nobody has correctly predicted March Madness either

 

[Oboeish20]

While no decision from UIL State office been made, Sharyland and Pioneer high school are currently under investigation due to confirmed UIL violations. While only a reprimand was given by the Region 15 committee, this issue has been elevated to the state level by the principal of Gladys Porter Early College High School.

Here’s the media coverage:

 

[RhythmicTuba]

  On 10/30/2024 at 6:45 PM, WanderingTraveler said:

which is why nobody has correctly predicted March Madness 

Expand  

Yet* 😜

[Baritone Legend]

  On 10/30/2024 at 12:04 AM, Samuel Culper said:

There have been years that I thought Rouse might beat Cedar Park.

This isn't one of those years.

Expand  

While I think there is an ok possibility for them to beat CP, I think CP might take it again. But it'll be close for sure!

[lowbrass]

1)lonestar

2)rouse

3)Lebanon trail

4)leander

5) aledo

6)hendrickson 

7)cen10

8)roma

9)friendswood

10)argyle

11) wakeland

12) cedar park

[utee94]

Like pretty much everywhere else in the state, there are decent rain chances in San Antonio on Monday and Tuesday.  While the performance area is sheltered within the Alamodome, all props and equipment are unloaded in the open air parking lot, and the front ensemble warm up areas are also outside in the elements.  That means all of the synth carts and other electronics will be at least somewhat exposed.  

I really hope the rain holds off and doesn't affect the equipment.

[WanderingTraveler]

  On 10/30/2024 at 8:50 PM, utee94 said:

Like pretty much everywhere else in the state, there are decent rain chances in San Antonio on Monday and Tuesday.  While the performance area is sheltered within the Alamodome, all props and equipment are unloaded in the open air parking lot, and the front ensemble warm up areas are also outside in the elements.  That means all of the synth carts and other electronics will be at least somewhat exposed.  

I really hope the rain holds off and doesn't affect the equipment.

Expand  

Exactly what I was thinking, this would be a logistical nightmare…

[SaxA36]

  On 10/30/2024 at 8:50 PM, lowbrass said:

1)lonestar

2)rouse

3)Lebanon trail

4)leander

5) aledo

6)hendrickson 

7)cen10

8)roma

9)friendswood

10)argyle

11) wakeland

12) cedar park

Expand  

try not to make it obvious you go to lonestar challenge level IMPOSSIBLE 

[Tubalord11]

  On 10/30/2024 at 6:21 PM, BariSaxyGuy said:

I see predictions and the top 6 all make sense, but I have seen some that have BC and CH in the finals but I don't see Midlo. I have seen both shows and they beat both at area and beat CH in prelims of the Mansfield POC and was barely behind BC at BOA Waco. I know its a very close race but what are yalls thoughts? 

Expand  

I think Midlo has a strong shot at finals, but they have a very unfortunate prelims time. Anything is possible with a super strong performance, but unfortunately this is the type of competition where even for super strong programs, having a super early performance time has an impact simply bc of how many bands are competing in prelims and how deep this contest is with talent, but I’d be so happy to see them in finals. 

[RhythmicTuba]

  On 10/31/2024 at 12:01 AM, Tubalord11 said:

but unfortunately this is the type of competition where even for super strong programs, having a super early performance time has an impact

Expand  

Hebron laughs at this comment with their 9:15 performance time this saturday.

[Tubalord11]

  On 10/31/2024 at 12:48 AM, RhythmicTuba said:

Hebron laughs at this comment with their 9:15 performance time this saturday.

Expand  

Mainly talking about programs that aren’t consistent finalist at state or SASR that are either having a super strong season or have been on the rise lately. Hebron is going to be completely fine. 😂

[Kimjungbassoon]

  On 10/30/2024 at 9:23 PM, SaxA36 said:

try not to make it obvious you go to lonestar challenge level IMPOSSIBLE 

Expand  

The list was obviously a joke because there are schools list that are not at the contest.

[Tubalord11]

  On 10/30/2024 at 6:52 PM, Oboeish20 said:

While no decision from UIL State office been made, Sharyland and Pioneer high school are currently under investigation due to confirmed UIL violations. While only a reprimand was given by the Region 15 committee, this issue has been elevated to the state level by the principal of Gladys Porter Early College High School.

Here’s the media coverage:

 

Expand  

Saw this this morning, hope everything gets cleared up and the two bands didn't violate any rules. Would suck if the kids got penalized for a choice made by the directors...

[RhythmicTuba]

  On 10/31/2024 at 1:59 AM, Tubalord11 said:

Saw this this morning, hope everything gets cleared up and the two bands didn't violate any rules. Would suck if the kids got penalized for a choice made by the directors...

Expand  

i did some research and it seems they did violate some rules, UIL has released that they will be reprimanded but have not said what that will entail.

[seafoodbuffet]

  On 10/31/2024 at 12:48 AM, RhythmicTuba said:

Hebron laughs at this comment with their 9:15 performance time this saturday.

Expand  

I mean, Hebron is such a powerhouse that they could have their performance from a month ago and still make state  (placing behind the other powerhouses in this area). The elite programs are just that far ahead of the mid pack programs at this point. Case in point, at BOA Austin, Rouse, as defending champs, got to pick their prelims spot and chose to go on first due to heat. They comfortably made finals and medaled.

[utee94]

I think the CP kids are starting to take it as a challenge.  11:00 AM performance time at BOA-Austin, 9:45 AM performance time at UIL Area Prelims, and now a 10:00 AM performance time at UIL State Prelims.  My own kids actually prefer early performance times, they feel fresher and they like to knock it out early and then just wait for the results.

 

[rouseglazer1]

does anyone know if the contest is being livestreamed again this year? and if so on what platform?

[WanderingTraveler]

  On 10/30/2024 at 6:52 PM, Oboeish20 said:

While no decision from UIL State office been made, Sharyland and Pioneer high school are currently under investigation due to confirmed UIL violations. While only a reprimand was given by the Region 15 committee, this issue has been elevated to the state level by the principal of Gladys Porter Early College High School.

Here’s the media coverage:

 

Expand  

Update on the situation. 

[WanderingTraveler]

  On 10/31/2024 at 4:56 PM, rouseglazer1 said:

does anyone know if the contest is being livestreamed again this year? and if so on what platform?

Expand  

https://www.nfhsnetwork.com/search/?query=marching band This is where the UIL said they are providing all Area/State level livestreams.

More info: https://www.uiltexas.org/music/marching-band/state

[rouseglazer1]

  On 10/31/2024 at 5:02 PM, WanderingTraveler said:

https://www.nfhsnetwork.com/search/?query=marching band This is where the UIL said they are providing all Area/State level livestreams.

More info: https://www.uiltexas.org/music/marching-band/state

Expand  

ewwwwwww nfhs (thank you for the info)

[hjssjeh]

Any opinions On A&m consolidated and Cs? I think the csisd bands could make a run for a finals spot this year, especially consolidated 

[Baritone Legend]

  On 10/31/2024 at 6:38 PM, hjssjeh said:

Any pinions On A&m consolidated and Cs? I think the csisd bands could make a run for a finals spot this year, especially consolidated 

Expand  

I'm not too sure, I have not seen their show this year, but I bet it could be possible! we'll have to see though for sure!

[rouseglazer1]

not entirely related but still somewhat related to smbc, a few years back I believe dallas highland park was dominating the 5a smbc scene and now it seems like they're struggling even just in their own area. does anyone know anything about this?

[lhbenlee]

  On 10/31/2024 at 8:11 PM, rouseglazer1 said:

not entirely related but still somewhat related to smbc, a few years back I believe dallas highland park was dominating the 5a smbc scene and now it seems like they're struggling even just in their own area. does anyone know anything about this?

Expand  

I believe they are 6a now.