Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

yeah tell me about it

 

pearland's scores were all over the place.... one judge has us 4th in music then the other judge had us 9th

 

which kept us from making state....little disappointing

  • Replies 121
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

I'll be honest. I thought the judging was pretty much accurate...

 

Spring was pretty good, just barely better than Brazoswood... Brazoswood got 2 1st place votes, so they were right up there... I was pretty dissappointed in the Woodlands... The show is a little weak for such a great band, and the thing that hurt them the most was timing problems... They were all over the place in parts of the show... Ya, they're consistently a great band, but look, you got beat. No use in whining about it. If it's such a big deal, just do better and don't blame the judges. Also everyone is complaining about Pearland. I honestly didn't have them in either... The whole "We beat Brazoswood at Galena Park" argument doesn't work either, since if you look at the galena park recaps, one judge had Brazoswood as a 90 out of 200 for drill design. Are you kidding me? I bet he mean't 190 and forgot the 1. Even then, Brazoswood would have won that contest with even 30 or 40 points more in that caption... That plus the judges were nobodys... Look at BOA, that was the first legitimate read on all these bands, and those results look pretty much like what happened last night... End of story...

Posted

I'm posting this mostly to clarify for the people who seem to believe that The Woodlands is 'whining' or anything about coming in 3rd at area; we aren't.

 

A few people I've talked to are disappointed about coming in 3rd place, as we thought we had done fairly well. We are not 'angry' about judging or anything of the sort, just slightly disappointed. We are excited about going to state, and hope to have better runs there.

Posted

i think area f needed a better announcer

 

she was so unenthusiastic and monotone and sounded like she didnt want to spend her saturday at the contest

 

when you hear an unethusiastic announcer it doesnt give you much enthusiasm before you perform

Posted
  the_DRUM_MAJOR said:
i really enjoyed watching college park's show, is there any mp3 or video of it online?

I'm going to get my mom to record it at the game on Saturday, and I will try to upload it google video or something.

Posted
  MmCheezItsYay said:
omg... yes... every time i heard her voice i kept thinking even i could do a way better job announcing... and i could barely understand what she was even saying...

Hah, exactly. Remember when they took forever to announce the results in the finals? I thought she had like died or something. :wacko:

Posted

Results from Area J1 J2 J3 J4 J5 Total Rank

Spring 2 1 1 2 1 7

Brazoswood 1 2 3 1 2 9

The Woodlands 3 8 2 3 3 19

Klein 5 7 7 4 4 27

Clear Brook 4 4 5 9 6 28

Pearland 6 9 4 6 5 30

Clear Lake 7 5 6 7 7 32

Kingwood 9 3 10 5 8 35

College Park 8 6 8 8 10 40

Klein Forest 10 10 9 10 9 48

Posted
  ClarinetFever747 said:
i think area f needed a better announcer

 

she was so unenthusiastic and monotone and sounded like she didnt want to spend her saturday at the contest

 

when you hear an unethusiastic announcer it doesnt give you much enthusiasm before you perform

She's probably the same one who did the GPISD contest AND the Region 19 UIL too...REALLY boring and she reminded me of that Clear Eyes guy. But she did make me laugh at GPISD contest when she completely mispronounced up our DMs' names

Posted

what is wrong w/ ppl's contest ediquette? i had like 5 ppl come up to me after area finals and ask me how it felt to know that our best wasn't good enough. how rude is that? and they were all from the same band.

 

and then some lady in the stands by my mom had something to say about everyone. why do ppl have to be so rude at contest? it's not everyone... but it shouldn't be anyone.

Posted
  mitchellbc said:
what is wrong w/ ppl's contest ediquette? i had like 5 ppl come up to me after area finals and ask me how it felt to know that our best wasn't good enough. how rude is that? and they were all from the same band.

wow... that is really rude... im pretty sure that wasnt spring ppl... hopefully

Posted
  dciguy085 said:
I'll be honest. I thought the judging was pretty much accurate...

 

Spring was pretty good, just barely better than Brazoswood... Brazoswood got 2 1st place votes, so they were right up there... I was pretty dissappointed in the Woodlands... The show is a little weak for such a great band, and the thing that hurt them the most was timing problems... They were all over the place in parts of the show... Ya, they're consistently a great band, but look, you got beat. No use in whining about it. If it's such a big deal, just do better and don't blame the judges. Also everyone is complaining about Pearland. I honestly didn't have them in either... The whole "We beat Brazoswood at Galena Park" argument doesn't work either, since if you look at the galena park recaps, one judge had Brazoswood as a 90 out of 200 for drill design. Are you kidding me? I bet he mean't 190 and forgot the 1. Even then, Brazoswood would have won that contest with even 30 or 40 points more in that caption... That plus the judges were nobodys... Look at BOA, that was the first legitimate read on all these bands, and those results look pretty much like what happened last night... End of story...

what one person says doesn't represent the entire band being mad.

 

i don't think anyone is complaining. we just know how inconsistent UIL judging is.

Posted
  ClaireAnnette07 said:
She's probably the same one who did the GPISD contest AND the Region 19 UIL too...REALLY boring and she reminded me of that Clear Eyes guy. But she did make me laugh at GPISD contest when she completely mispronounced up our DMs' names

  Quote

 

haha, she IS boring... GPISD needs to hire someone like the BOA guy for their announcer - he sounds cool...lol

 

She mispronounced the name of our show THREE times!! how hard is it to say: Hypar Effect - she was saying Hyper Effect...lol

Posted
  iplayband07 said:
we just know how inconsistent UIL judging is.

agreed.

 

on another note: Spring's show was pretty cool, they didnt have all the distractions that everyone else had (woodlands - trees and yardline markers i think; pearland - random tower, narrator; one of the klein bands - flowers?)

 

i'm not knocking any of those bands, but just saying that these distractions can mask some bad marching. Spring was cool

Posted

Thanks a lot!

 

I think that is a reason why I really like our show so much this year, because we've mostly concentrated on our music. I love our music this year, because all our pieces are so different from each other but they still have a connection, you know?

 

Out of all of them though, I love jam section the best, haha. :lol:

 

Not that I'm knocking down any bands that do use props and such - because I love the Woodlands' show, and Klein really impressed me (re: they were the flower band). [i didn't get to see Pearland, unfortunately. :(] I just really like the direction our directors took this year.

Posted
  ClarinetFever747 said:
i think area f needed a better announcer

 

she was so unenthusiastic and monotone and sounded like she didnt want to spend her saturday at the contest

 

when you hear an unethusiastic announcer it doesnt give you much enthusiasm before you perform

dude i totally agree.. that person that came over the system sounded sick .. so mono toned...

Posted
  n3rdu5 said:
Thanks a lot!

 

I think that is a reason why I really like our show so much this year, because we've mostly concentrated on our music. I love our music this year, because all our pieces are so different from each other but they still have a connection, you know?

 

Out of all of them though, I love jam section the best, haha.  :lol:

you guys had the "cool" clarinet solo right? i remembered there were several clarinet solos throughtout the day, bu only one was cool. the others were supposed to be beautiful and such, but on the marching field, they were soft and boring.

Posted

hahha, I'm guessing you are talking about us! yeah we have a clarinet solo that builds up into a huge jam section with the whole band, and ends with a high note held by the clarinet as the band runs wild and then a big note at the end.

 

haha. I love that.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...