Which is harder to make state

[acsc1312]

I think its harder in band simply because you have more chances with football. You get a chance to make state every year with football. with band you have to wait a whole year between state years. If you have a bad year, you have to wait another year and wait to see if the following year you have a good show. I dont now, its just that i think football players have more chances to make it.

[crazyjakeup]

lets do the math every two years a 5a band has the oppertunity to make state.

every year a 5a football team has a chance to make state.

 

lets say about 25 bands make it to state every two years

 

8 football teams make state every year meaning 16 teams (some twice so the number could be fewer) go every two years

 

band=about 25 ,is greater than , football 16

 

so now no one can say that band is harder because of numbers

[jakeup]

^ talk about a croud killer

[Xenon]

  jakeup said:

^ talk about a croud killer

Pure logic tends to do that.

[bluebellbrass07]

QUOTE (Tnilli @ Dec 6 2006, 01:30 AM)

Football works harder. Not a single one of you can convince me otherwise.

I'd have to say that really depends on where you come from.

[MartinHorn]

Wow the vote is tied right now.

[TX Suh-nare]

I'd say football.

Those guys have to practice MORE than we b.n.'s, and they have to either knock someone to the ground or expect to get rattled on a regular basis. Also think about the fact they have to learn all those plays, too.

 

To dumb it up, if you collide with a band member multiple times, you'll probably get cut. If you collide with another football player multiple times, you've had a good day.

[crazyjakeup]

good point...

 

 

 

 

(viva la topics!!!)