Pre-season predictions

[WestCoastCorpsFan]

  E3euph said:

because ima BD fan thats why

Look Im BD.

DAHHHHHHHHHHH.

*horn down

*jazz run

*hold

DAHHHHHHHHHHH.

*repeat

 

lol. But heck, it works.

[TRUMPet]

  Quote

Look Im BD.

DAHHHHHHHHHHH.

*horn down

*jazz run

*hold

DAHHHHHHHHHHH.

*repeat

 

lol. But heck, it works.

Might i also add winston churchill.

[ftwdrummer]

Prediction: Wherever the Cavies place, Phantom will be one spot below them. (See results starting with 2005)

 

Given the fact that in the recent past the Cadets' sequal shows have dropped four spots from the show they're doing a sequal of, I'm putting them sixth.

 

Wagering Cavies first (they always win the years after they don't in this millenium [2004, 2006])...ergo, Phantom second (wishful thinking, I know, but I can dream, can't I?)

 

Based on that, plus some rough guesses:

 

1) The Cavaliers

2) Phantom Regiment

3) Blue Devils

4) Santa Clara Vanguard

5) Carolina Crown

6) The Cadets

 

Again, though, EXTREME WAG's there...along with a whole heap of wishful thinking.

Edited January 7, 2008 by ftwdrummer

[E3euph]

  TRUMPet said:

Might i also add winston churchill.

 

why the hostility?

Edited January 13, 2008 by E3euph

[TRUMPet]

You from Churchill?

 

I give no credit to concert arcs. If i had to judge i would have marked a zero for marching in the balad (as well as the first min.) ... seeing as no one moved. And a moment of silence where the gaurd spins in spot. I just dont like it. oh and did i mention i really dont like voice overs...but this is the wrong post for this so ill leave this conversation be.

[mbui]

The marching activity is MORE than marching the entire 8-11 minutes, playing music, and etc. It's about being creative, being effective, and more importantly, being remembered. You can be the most amazing group when it comes to the technical parts of music and marching, but if it's not an effective show and it seems like that the show is "just there"..... than you're not going to be remembered.

 

God forbid that no one has ever stood still during a ballad before. Every band (and drum corps) does it. Aren't you supposed to stand still during the impact point of the ballad anyways?

[WestCoastCorpsFan]

  mbui said:

The marching activity is MORE than marching the entire 8-11 minutes, playing music, and etc. It's about being creative, being effective, and more importantly, being remembered. You can be the most amazing group when it comes to the technical parts of music and marching, but if it's not an effective show and it seems like that the show is "just there"..... than you're not going to be remembered.

 

God forbid that no one has ever stood still during a ballad before. Every band (and drum corps) does it. Aren't you supposed to stand still during the impact point of the ballad anyways?

Well, It's not like anyone knows the RIGHT way to do marching band or something. That's what makes bands unique. I semi-agree with TRUMPet... except I think he used a bad example. Im really not a fan of people crawling or hiding behind sheets for chunks of a show.

 

Mr. Bui. I think you are right in some aspects. One, I guess you could say most of the time bands/corps will hault in a Ballad. But, there is a certain amount of time you can pull this off in. It may be personal preference, but like I said, I really dont like watching an invisible band play a couple chords for minutes.

 

TRUMPet, I kind of agree with you, but calling out Churchills show probably wasnt a good example. The use of the longer than normal hault was effective. and the silence held meaning. Also, you may want to watch out on the voice thing... I believe your high school will have a choir singing, and you will be singing. : o

And, going into this new DCI world (aka The BOA takeover of DCI) the corps you're trying out for may need to use such devices just to stay competitive in the future...

 

end.

 

(btw, I think LD Bell is really good. Im just not a fan of the show design.)

Edited January 21, 2008 by WestCoastCorpsFan

[TRUMPet]

I want to start off saying i understand the moment of silence had meaning, I just don't like it (kinda old now).

  Quote

God forbid that no one has ever stood still during a ballad before. Every band (and drum corps) does it

mbui, i dont mind them standing still, they just did it for 1-2 min., the entirety of amazing grace... too long for my liking.

And as far as the voice thing goes, even if it is in my band i dont have to like it... (and i seem to remember you talking about how much you dislike it too

 

And really all of this is opinion based so...

[WestCoastCorpsFan]

  TRUMPet said:

I want to start off saying i understand the moment of silence had meaning, I just don't like it (kinda old now).

 

mbui, i dont mind them standing still, they just did it for 1-2 min., the entirety of amazing grace... too long for my liking.

And as far as the voice thing goes, even if it is in my band i dont have to like it... (and i seem to remember you talking about how much you dislike it too

 

And really all of this is opinion based so...

 

I think there are appropriate and inappropriate times for such.

[HashBrownJM]

I also have opinions. Imagine that!

[Danpod]

  HashBrownJM said:

I also have opinions. Imagine that!

 

Movable printed type?????? We must keep this from the Serfs lest they gain literacy and over-throw us.

[mbui]

  TRUMPet said:

I want to start off saying i understand the moment of silence had meaning, I just don't like it (kinda old now).

 

mbui, i dont mind them standing still, they just did it for 1-2 min., the entirety of amazing grace... too long for my liking.

And as far as the voice thing goes, even if it is in my band i dont have to like it... (and i seem to remember you talking about how much you dislike it too

About voiceovers....Me or WestCoastCorpsFan? I don't think I've ever brought up voiceovers. I like voiceovers. But, not in an excessive and poor manner. Winston Churchill's was nowhere close to excessive. It was tasteful and appropriate to me.

[TRUMPet]

  Quote

About voiceovers....Me or WestCoastCorpsFan?

Sorry 'bout the confusion ment to hit enter twice I was talkin to CorpsFan

[WestCoastCorpsFan]

Update based on recordings from camps i have seen or heard:

 

1)Blue Devils

2)Santa Clara Vanguard

3) Cavaliers

4) Phantom Regiment

5) Cadets

6) Bluecoats

7) Carolina Crown

8) Colts

9) Madison Scouts

10) Glassmen

11) The Academy

12) Blue Stars

[TX Suh-nare]

1) Cavaliers

2) (TIE) BD and Cadets

4) BLOOOOOOOO!

5) Crown

6) SCV

7) Crown

8) Blue Knights

9) BAC

10) Blue Stars

11) Academy

12) Troopers (HA! I wish! But really) Glassmen

 

Here's my evidence

Since Vanguard's '89 performance, only three corps have ever won a ring w/o sharing it, BD, Cavies, and Cadets. Since I am a very firm believer in politics, I don't see why the Board would let anything else happen.

 

To me, Crown had a spectacular show, but a lot of corps have problems rebounding after really popular years. SCV '89-'90, PR '96-'97, Phantom '03-'04, Cadets '03-'04. All the latter shows were pretty good, but they couldn't match up to their status of a year ago, so the points suffered.

 

I think the same might go for Colts. Plus, with the growth Blue Stars had over the last couple of years after coming back to (at the time) Div. 1, they have taken the right steps to be serious contenders for a spot on Saturday. Same with Academy. Both have incredible vet return rates, which is pivotal to improving a corps.

 

Glassmen sounds great, but until their drill becomes more difficult, they aren't going anywhere. Plus, I don't think their drumline has been the same since Colin McNutt left back in '02. That line carried them into top 6 back in '01 and '02 (scoring 2nd at least once in there), but if they can't get the drums back to McNutt's caliber, it'll hold them back.

[dmbalash]

  TX Suh-nare said:

Here's my evidence

Since Vanguard's '89 performance, only three corps have ever won a ring w/o sharing it, BD, Cavies, and Cadets. Since I am a very firm believer in politics, I don't see why the Board would let anything else happen.

 

And Star back in 1991.

[HashBrownJM]

  TX Suh-nare said:

1) Cavaliers

2) (TIE) BD and Cadets

4) BLOOOOOOOO!

5) Crown

6) SCV

7) Crown

8) Blue Knights

9) BAC

10) Blue Stars

11) Academy

12) Troopers (HA! I wish! But really) Glassmen

 

Here's my evidence

Since Vanguard's '89 performance, only three corps have ever won a ring w/o sharing it, BD, Cavies, and Cadets. Since I am a very firm believer in politics, I don't see why the Board would let anything else happen.

 

To me, Crown had a spectacular show, but a lot of corps have problems rebounding after really popular years. SCV '89-'90, PR '96-'97, Phantom '03-'04, Cadets '03-'04. All the latter shows were pretty good, but they couldn't match up to their status of a year ago, so the points suffered.

 

I think the same might go for Colts. Plus, with the growth Blue Stars had over the last couple of years after coming back to (at the time) Div. 1, they have taken the right steps to be serious contenders for a spot on Saturday. Same with Academy. Both have incredible vet return rates, which is pivotal to improving a corps.

 

Glassmen sounds great, but until their drill becomes more difficult, they aren't going anywhere. Plus, I don't think their drumline has been the same since Colin McNutt left back in '02. That line carried them into top 6 back in '01 and '02 (scoring 2nd at least once in there), but if they can't get the drums back to McNutt's caliber, it'll hold them back.

 

Thanks for the love, man.

[thesnareguy]

Cavaliers will take it.

[ftwdrummer]

  TX Suh-nare said:

Here's my evidence

Since Vanguard's '89 performance, only three corps have ever won a ring w/o sharing it, BD, Cavies, and Cadets. Since I am a very firm believer in politics, I don't see why the Board would let anything else happen.

 

You forgot Star in '91.

[TX Suh-nare]

Oops. Thanks for catching that.

And I'm suprised noone caught my Crown typo yet.

 

Due to that, I have to redo my Top 6

1) Cavies

2) (TIE) BD & Cadets

4) BLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

5) SCV

6) Crown

[ftwdrummer]

OK...now that BD's officially announced its show (see here), I'm rewriting my wishful thinking of a few months ago to call...a tie.

 

1) Blue Devils, The Cavaliers

3) Phantom Regiment

4) Santa Clara Vanguard

5) Carolina Crown

6) The Cadets

[WestCoastCorpsFan]

  thesnareguy said:

Cavaliers will take it.

Hey drum corps people, did anyone else find ---^ this comment ironic? lol. haha, we all know what the cavaliers take... oh, you know, i mean, championships... right, thats it.

[Danpod]

  WestCoastCorpsFan said:

Hey drum corps people, did anyone else find ---^ this comment ironic? lol. haha, we all know what the cavaliers take... oh, you know, i mean, championships... right, thats it.

 

Excuse me while I giggle like a school girl.

[Trumpet Master]

  Danpod said:

Excuse me while I giggle like a school girl.

 

Have we ever gotten confirmation about the couple's bus for the cavies? That sounds like a DanPod investigates podcast to me.

[ftwdrummer]

  Trumpet Master said:

Have we ever gotten confirmation about the couple's bus for the cavies? That sounds like a DanPod investigates podcast to me.

 

For some reason, reading that made me laugh harder than anything since the first time I saw "Powerthirst"