I MARCH Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 (edited) Fossil Ridge H.S., TX8:00 Palestine H.S., TX8:15 Winnsboro H.S., TX8:30 Wakeland H.S., TX8:45 North Shore Sr. H.S., TX9:00 Clovis H.S., NM9:15 L.D. Bell H.S., TX9:30 BREAK Lovejoy H.S., TX10:00 Skiatook H.S., OK10:15 Haltom H.S., TX10:30 Trinity H.S., TX10:45 Newman Smith H.S., TX11:00 Mansfield H.S., TX11:15 Creekview H.S., TX11:30 Coppell H.S., TX11:45 LUNCH Leander H.S., TX12:45 Martin H.S., TX1:00 Connally H.S., TX1:15 Berkner H.S., TX1:30 Hebron H.S., TX1:45 Ronald Reagan H.S., TX2:00 Richland H.S., TX2:15 BREAKMarcus H.S., TX2:45 Aledo H.S., TX3:00 Legacy H.S., TX3:15 Birdville H.S., TX3:30 Colleyville Heritage H.S., TX3:45 Cypress Falls H.S., TX4:00 William B. Travis H.S., TX4:15 Edited September 29, 2009 by I MARCH Quote
rpd Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 No particular order: L.D. Bell H.S., TX9:30 Haltom H.S., TX10:30 Mansfield H.S., TX11:15 Coppell H.S., TX11:45 Leander H.S., TX12:45 Connally H.S., TX1:15 Berkner H.S., TX1:30 Hebron H.S., TX1:45 Richland H.S., TX2:15 Marcus H.S., TX2:45 My bubble bands: Martin H.S., TX1:00 Ronald Reagan H.S., TX2:00 (I think Reagan could very well be a finalist, but Im not sure how there going to respond in there 2nd year after the school split) North Shore Sr. H.S., TX9:00 Quote
I MARCH Posted September 30, 2009 Author Posted September 30, 2009 rpd said: No particular order: L.D. Bell H.S., TX9:30 Haltom H.S., TX10:30 Mansfield H.S., TX11:15 Coppell H.S., TX11:45 Leander H.S., TX12:45 Connally H.S., TX1:15 Berkner H.S., TX1:30 Hebron H.S., TX1:45 Richland H.S., TX2:15 Marcus H.S., TX2:45 My bubble bands: Martin H.S., TX1:00 Ronald Reagan H.S., TX2:00 (I think Reagan could very well be a finalist, but Im not sure how there going to respond in there 2nd year after the school split) North Shore Sr. H.S., TX9:00 I agree but i hope North Shore makes it. Quote
JustAddWat3r Posted September 30, 2009 Posted September 30, 2009 No Colleyville Heritage or Legacy? Heck even Birdville deserves a mention. After all, they did beat Hebron in marching at ToC Prelims. Quote
bingogooberman Posted September 30, 2009 Posted September 30, 2009 JustAddWat3r said: No Colleyville Heritage or Legacy? Heck even Birdville deserves a mention. After all, they did beat Hebron in marching at ToC Prelims. let's not forget Newman Smith, sure we kinda blew it last year at BOA, but judging from our TOC exhibition (which scored quite well), and the overall improvement of show design over last year, I wouldn't say it's out of the question. Not terribly likely, but still possible. Quote
JustAddWat3r Posted September 30, 2009 Posted September 30, 2009 (edited) Here's how I see it: All of the following bands are possible finalists broken down into 5 tiers (They are in no particular order within their tiers). Tier 1 L.D. Bell H.S. Marcus H.S. Tier 2 Hebron H.S. Coppell H.S. Richland H.S. Tier 3 Haltom H.S. Mansfield H.S. Berkner H.S. Colleyville Heritage H.S. Tier 4 Ronald Reagan H.S. Legacy H.S. Cypress Falls H.S. Connally H.S. Leander H.S. North Shore Sr. H.S. Tier 5 Newman Smith H.S. Creekview H.S. Aledo H.S. Birdville H.S. Martin H.S. Fossil Ridge H.S Did I forget anyone? Edited September 30, 2009 by JustAddWat3r Quote
ftwdrummer Posted September 30, 2009 Posted September 30, 2009 JustAddWat3r said: Here's how I see it: All of the following bands are possible finalists broken down into 5 tiers (They are in no particular order within their tiers). Tier 1 L.D. Bell H.S., TX9:30 Marcus H.S., TX2:45 Tier 2 Hebron H.S., TX1:45 Coppell H.S., TX11:45 Richland H.S., TX2:15 Tier 3 Haltom H.S., TX10:30 Mansfield H.S., TX11:15 Berkner H.S., TX1:30 Colleyville Heritage H.S., TX3:45 Tier 4 Ronald Reagan H.S., TX2:00 Legacy H.S., TX3:15 Cypress Falls H.S., TX4:00 Connally H.S., TX1:15 Leander H.S., TX12:45 North Shore Sr. H.S., TX9:00 Tier 5 Newman Smith H.S., TX11:00 Creekview H.S., TX11:30 Aledo H.S., TX3:00 Birdville H.S., TX3:30 Did I forget anyone? I would bump Hebron down to Tier 3 and replace with Haltom or Berkner. Hebron's director is now the director at Reagan, right? Or am I inventing things again? I don't think this one will affect them too adversely...but I would be a little more wary with them. And you forgot Martin and Fossil Ridge. Fossil Ridge could be a tier 4, but probably a tier 5 just due to performance time if nothing else. Martin should be a solid tier 5, as well. Quote
longhornsax Posted September 30, 2009 Posted September 30, 2009 I'm really curious to see how Hebron stacks up against the big boys this year. New director or not, this is a program that continues to improve with each passing year. And if the ToC was any indicator, I'd say they're definitely taking it up another level this year. Quote
JustAddWat3r Posted September 30, 2009 Posted September 30, 2009 ftwdrummer said: I would bump Hebron down to Tier 3 and replace with Haltom or Berkner. Hebron's director is now the director at Reagan, right? Or am I inventing things again? I don't think this one will affect them too adversely...but I would be a little more wary with them. And you forgot Martin and Fossil Ridge. Fossil Ridge could be a tier 4, but probably a tier 5 just due to performance time if nothing else. Martin should be a solid tier 5, as well. I agree with Martin and Fossil Ridge and i just added them in there. However after seeing Hebron at ToC, i strongly believe they are tier 2 material. Quote
I MARCH Posted September 30, 2009 Author Posted September 30, 2009 well the thing is hebron should be a tier 2 but as for birdville thats about right. i mean they're a great band but not at that level. and Hebron wiped that competition up. Quote
ftwdrummer Posted September 30, 2009 Posted September 30, 2009 JustAddWat3r said: I agree with Martin and Fossil Ridge and i just added them in there. However after seeing Hebron at ToC, i strongly believe they are tier 2 material. That's reasonable. I haven't seen any of these yet (and probably won't; one of the side effects of going to college in Houston, after spending 4 years in the D/FW band scene), so all I have to go by is what's been on here. Quote
aaron067 Posted September 30, 2009 Posted September 30, 2009 Andy Sealy is still at Hebron. It was their third director who moved to Reagan. All I know about the former assistant is that he is now a third-year teacher; so, with that in mind, I'd be more worried about Reagan than Hebron. Quote
ftwdrummer Posted September 30, 2009 Posted September 30, 2009 Good to know. Thanks for the clarification. Given that information, I wholeheartedly agree with putting Hebron in tier 2. Quote
I MARCH Posted September 30, 2009 Author Posted September 30, 2009 North Shore Should be in Tier 3 i think. and im not being biased. Quote
bingogooberman Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 I MARCH said: North Shore Should be in Tier 3 i think. and im not being biased. considering North Shore hasn't ever competed at BOA or with practically any of the bands attending, I would go ahead and leave them off the list entirely since there's really no knowing where they'll place. Although, from what I do know about NS, i would say maybe you are a little biased (tier 3 is quite generous). While i'm at it- TIER 1- L.D. Bell Marcus TIER 2- Richland Hebron Haltom TIER 3- Berkner Ronald Reagan Cypress Falls Mansfield Coppell TIER 4- Conally Legacy Colleyville Heritage Newman Smith Martin Leander TIER 5- Fossil Ridge Creekview Aledo Birdville Quote
the terminator Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 yeah i would like to say wakeland will be tier 4 or 5 but i also admit they have not really competed against the bands of this caliber, but i think they can finish in the top 15 Quote
JustAddWat3r Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 bingogooberman said: TIER 1-L.D. Bell Marcus TIER 2- Richland Hebron Haltom And there we have our 5 bands advancing to State from Area B....wow Quote
I MARCH Posted October 1, 2009 Author Posted October 1, 2009 bingogooberman said: considering North Shore hasn't ever competed at BOA or with practically any of the bands attending, I would go ahead and leave them off the list entirely since there's really no knowing where they'll place. Although, from what I do know about NS, i would say maybe you are a little biased (tier 3 is quite generous).While i'm at it- TIER 1- L.D. Bell Marcus TIER 2- Richland Hebron Haltom TIER 3- Berkner Ronald Reagan Cypress Falls Mansfield Coppell TIER 4- Conally Legacy Colleyville Heritage Newman Smith Martin Leander TIER 5- Fossil Ridge Creekview Aledo Birdville Well your right and ur wrong. North shore has never competed in boa but they really should be in tier 3. They have earned there right. and im not really being biased. i've been studying the bands who are competing at boa and i've been comparing different competitions that they have been to. but i just think North shore is good enough to be in tier 3. but i don't know about the whole idea that they shouldn't be on there at all. Quote
JustAddWat3r Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 I MARCH said: Well your right and ur wrong. North shore has never competed in boa but they really should be in tier 3. They have earned there right. and im not really being biased. i've been studying the bands who are competing at boa and i've been comparing different competitions that they have been to. but i just think North shore is good enough to be in tier 3. but i don't know about the whole idea that they shouldn't be on there at all. Would you mind posting your own Tiers? I'm just curious to see what you think of this competition. Quote
Danpod Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 Let's all get something straight. If you're still in high school and you're comparing yourself to other programs, you are biased. There's not much you can do about that. Perspective is limited when you're in the organization. There is really not much you can do about it. I've experienced this as a former marcher and as an instructor. For a program to think that they've earned something in a system that they have never competed in before is naive. Quote
bingogooberman Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 I MARCH said: Well your right and ur wrong. North shore has never competed in boa but they really should be in tier 3. They have earned there right. and im not really being biased. i've been studying the bands who are competing at boa and i've been comparing different competitions that they have been to. but i just think North shore is good enough to be in tier 3. but i don't know about the whole idea that they shouldn't be on there at all. Well i'm not saying North Shore isn't in finals contention, because they are, it's just placing them in a particular tier is a difficult thing to do, but i wouldn't put them in 3, but that's just me. Quote
Montoya Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 Danpod said: Let's all get something straight. If you're still in high school and you're comparing yourself to other programs, you are biased. There's not much you can do about that. Perspective is limited when you're in the organization. There is really not much you can do about it. I've experienced this as a former marcher and as an instructor. For a program to think that they've earned something in a system that they have never competed in before is naive. ...And if I actually marched in Crockett '93? Quote
Xenon Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 Montoya said: ...And if I actually marched in Crockett '93? Then that isn't bias, it is pure unadulterated fact of tragedy. Quote
dmbalash Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 Montoya said: ...And if I actually marched in Crockett '93? Then you are old. Quote
JustAddWat3r Posted October 1, 2009 Posted October 1, 2009 Montoya said: ...And if I actually marched in Crockett '93? Not this again...I still don't quite understand what happened that year... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.