moose_eggs Posted October 9, 2011 Posted October 9, 2011 My opinions: Marcus plays extremely well. This helps them not only in music, but in GE. CTJ, SFA, TWHS, LDBell all had more difficult and engaging visual packages. Would have easily given this caption to Bell. but they were just not as clean. Clean is counting more and more these days as more bands are achieving at a very high level. It is impossible to get into finals with show design only and that didn't really used to be the case. Quote
Xenon Posted October 9, 2011 Posted October 9, 2011 moose_eggs said: Not really. Bell beat Marcus by 2.8 points and swept all caption in prelims and finals at the Arlington Regional in 2010, which was the same weekend as the houston regional this weekend. Then Marcus beat LD Bell at BOA San Antonio that same year. So Im not sure I would call it huge. It is definitely huge, just not insurmountable with work through the season. But it is of the level of difference that individual variations in performance on that day are unlikely (without completely falling apart) to cause a difference in placement. Quote
Mellophone77 Posted October 10, 2011 Posted October 10, 2011 (edited) And we got prelims scores today: http://www.musicforall.org/images/stories/...XCO.Prelims.pdf Few things I noticed after scanning it a bit: - Pflugerville tied Brazoswood for the tenth place spot going into finals (placed 11th due to General Effect and apparently should've made finals due to a BOA rule that states that if two bands tie for the final spot into finals, they both advance) - Vandegrift placed 12th--just .15 of a point behind Pflugerville/Brazoswood - Marcus beat out Bell by 1.05 Edited October 10, 2011 by Mellophone77 Quote
Xenon Posted October 10, 2011 Posted October 10, 2011 Mellophone77 said: And we got prelims scores today: http://www.musicforall.org/images/stories/...XCO.Prelims.pdf Few things I noticed after scanning it a bit: - Pflugerville tied Brazoswood for the tenth place spot going into finals (placed 11th due to General Effect and apparently should've made finals due to a BOA rule that states that if two bands tie for the final spot into finals, they both advance) - Vandegrift placed 12th just .15 of a point behind Pflugerville/Brazoswood - Marcus beat out Bell by 1.05 You are absolutely, right; Pflugerville should have advanced to Finals to make 11 bands in Finals! BOA Adjudication Handbook (emphasis mine) said: If two or more bands have a tie in their final score, the high placement will be awarded to the bandwith the higher raw score (subtotal before penalties). If after using this criterion a tie still exists, the highest General Effect total will be used to determine placement. This procedure will only be applied in class champion and finals competitions. When bands achieve the same (tie) score in prelims, and when such score causes a placement tie for the last position advancing to the finals competition, each band with a tie score will advance. Quote
CPbass Posted October 11, 2011 Posted October 11, 2011 Has anyone seen the finals score spread sheet? Quote
RWood Posted October 11, 2011 Posted October 11, 2011 I was just looking and haven't seen the breakdown of the scores. MFA also hasn't posted the prelim scores that I've seen on their website, although I've heard Cedar Park was 5th overall in prelims. Quote
bksatx Posted October 11, 2011 Posted October 11, 2011 Prelims scores: 1) 85.45 Marcus 2) 84.40 L.D. Bell 3) 82.15 Stephen F. Austin 4) 81.85 The Woodlands 5) 80.25 Cedar Park 6) 79.40 Claudia Taylor Johnson 7) 79.30 Winston Churchill 8) 79.05 Ronald Reagan 9) 78.50 Lafayette 10) 74.75 Brazoswood 11) 74.75 Pflugerville (tie broken by GE) 12) 74.60 Vandegrift 13) 74.50 The Woodlands College Park 14) 74.20 Friendswood 15) 74.15 Cypress Falls 16) 72.90 Oak Ridge 17) 71.70 Judson 18) 69.75 McNeil 19) 69.70 Cedar Ridge 20) 69.25 Alvin 21) 68.80 Clear Brook 22) 68.25 Westwood 23) 67.10 Clear Lake 24) 67.05 William B. Travis 25) 66.20 Calallen 26) 64.20 John Marshall 27) 64.00 Kaufman Quote
RWood Posted October 11, 2011 Posted October 11, 2011 Full score sheet for prelims: http://www.musicforall.org/images/stories/...XCO.Prelims.pdf For finals: http://www.musicforall.org/images/stories/...TXCO.Finals.pdf And Pflugerville should have marched in the finals as well. See here for the explanation: http://www.musicforall.org/resources/fall-.../2011/conroe-tx Quote
longhornsax Posted October 11, 2011 Posted October 11, 2011 RWood said: And Pflugerville should have marched in the finals as well. See here for the explanation: http://www.musicforall.org/resources/fall-.../2011/conroe-tx Wow...Huge mistake there on the part of the guys running this competition. I'm curious as to how this could have possibly been missed? Gotta read the fine print. Disappointing for the kids at P-ville. Quote
Thomas Posted October 11, 2011 Posted October 11, 2011 Wow. Also, from 14th to 10th place, the difference was .55 points! Quote
Danpod Posted October 11, 2011 Posted October 11, 2011 Xenon said: You are absolutely, right; Pflugerville should have advanced to Finals to make 11 bands in Finals! I'm curious as to how this was overlooked. I know a few people who work over at BOA and I am certain that it was nothing more than an honest mistake. Even so, that has to sting a little bit if you're Pflugerville. Quote
mellopwn1 Posted October 11, 2011 Posted October 11, 2011 It really is unfortunate for Pflugerville, especially after their 15th place (also 1 out from Finals) Prelims performance last year at San Antonio. I can imagine that with such a loaded lineup and hectic schedule, it was an accidental oversight on BOA's part, but I still feel like Pflugerville should get some sort of formal apology. I hope Eric Martin or someone else from BOA takes care of that; P-ville deserve it. Quote
Pvillepitcrew Posted October 11, 2011 Posted October 11, 2011 (edited) Danpod said: Even so, that has to sting a little bit if you're Pflugerville. Yes it did. Just found out a little while ago. Anybody who follows this or has done this knows the amount of prep that goes in to these shows. All the bands I saw did an amazing job and Im glad Im not one of the judges! I know the kids and directors wanted so badly to perform in the finals. It is an honor to perform with such great Tx High School programs. We will be there for the next one. Thanks for all your support. The band really appreciates it. Edited October 11, 2011 by Pvillepitcrew Quote
Iheartband Posted October 12, 2011 Posted October 12, 2011 Pvillepitcrew said: Yes it did. Just found out a little while ago. Anybody who follows this or has done this knows the amount of prep that goes in to these shows. All the bands I saw did an amazing job and Im glad Im not one of the judges! I know the kids and directors wanted so badly to perform in the finals. It is an honor to perform with such great Tx High School programs. We will be there for the next one. Thanks for all your support. The band really appreciates it. What a classy response! You have a great outlook on the situation, best of luck to you this season! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.