Rankings on HORNRANK.COM

[LostChoirGuy]

I think they will be around 28th

[JeremiahW]

  On 10/29/2017 at 4:26 PM, Band band band 212 said:

Do y'all believe haltom deserves a spot on horn ranks with what they put out to the public yesterday ?? Beating several incredible groups ??

 

prolly

[JC18]

  On 10/30/2017 at 4:38 AM, JeremiahW said:

prolly

Hm... I'm gonna guess... 27?

[Band band band 212]

  On 10/30/2017 at 3:45 PM, JC18 said:

Hm... I'm gonna guess... 27?

You have skills

[CTJBandPops]

lets see what this weeks standing look like after BOA SA

 

2.            Flower Mound                                       6^th in Finals (below # 3, 4, 5, 7, 9)

3.            Avon                                                     4^th in Finals (below # 4, 5, 7)

4.            Hebron                                                 2^nd in Finals (below # 5)

5.            Claudia Taylor Johnson                       1^st in Finals (Above # 2, 3, 4)

7.            Vandegrift                                            3^rd in Finals (Above # 2, 3)

9.            Reagan                                                5^th in Finals (above # 2)

 

should be interesting - 11 other programs in the top 30 that performed that will impact the standing (I assume)

[natertater21000]

Gonna be hard to watch how far Leander will fall, still in complete shock at 14th.

[LostChoirGuy]

I'm sure Leander will still be top 25

[LeanderMomma]

  On 11/5/2017 at 3:37 PM, natertater21000 said:

Gonna be hard to watch how far Leander will fall, still in complete shock at 14th.

The scores were so tight at the bottom. It was crazy. I know the kids are disappointed but WOW...WHAT A LEVEL OF BRILLIANCE! This year the high level of competition was just outstanding in San Antonio. No shame!!

[Bandwoww]

Keller should move up quite a lot as well. They were 9th and over a point ahead of 10th.

[snares]

My opinion is as follows:

1)CTJ

2)HEBRON

3)VANDEGRIFT

4)CARMEL

5)AVON

6)BROKEN ARROW

7)TARPON SPRINGS

8)FLOWER MOUND/REAGAN

10)MARCUS

[CTJBandPops]

  On 11/5/2017 at 7:50 PM, SnareSnare13 said:

My opinion is as follows:

1)CTJ

2)HEBRON

3)VANDEGRIFT

4)CARMEL

5)AVON

6)BROKEN ARROW

7)TARPON SPRINGS

8)FLOWER MOUND/REAGAN

10)MARCUS

I would be surprised to see Carmel taken out of 1st - but we will see

[principalagent]

I have a strong hunch that 1st will change.

[Nny14]

  On 11/5/2017 at 10:04 PM, banddad84 said:

 

I would be surprised to see Carmel taken out of 1st - but we will see

Not really. Carmel barely beat Avon, while CTJ was over a point of them.

[Band band band 212]

Do y’all think ld bell will go down a lot and what would happen to bands like cedar ridge ??? They would go up ?? But then that makes me think would that also bring wando and haltom up since the are all behind bell but beat cedar ridge that then beat bell less then a week before ??

[Bandwoww]

  On 11/6/2017 at 12:40 AM, Band band band 212 said:

Do y’all think ld bell will go down a lot and what would happen to bands like cedar ridge ??? They would go up ?? But then that makes me think would that also bring wando and haltom up since the are all behind bell but beat cedar ridge that then beat bell less then a week before ??

Bell, Leander, and The Woodlands should drop quite a lot

[LostChoirGuy]

I dont think the rankings will exactly mirror the standings at this competition. For instance, I don't think Leander will be as far as a 14th place finish would make them seem because their other results are consistent with more along a 10th place. Bands that are going to GNats probably wony fall quite as hard as it woulf seem either, so while the woodlands and round rock for instance will definitely fall, I dont think RR will fall out. Haltom probably wont move up with Cedar Ridge since their show finished last week. Cedar Ridge improving and having a great perfomance this week doesnt translate to haltom necessarily being better last week. I think they are safe in the 25-30 range. Pearland will likely join the next 10 which is cool and maybe dripping springs might make it to the next 10? I suppose I could just make up my predictions for what will happen and post them.

[Band band band 212]

  On 11/6/2017 at 12:56 AM, Bandwoww said:

 

Bell, Leander, and The Woodlands should drop quite a lot

Would that put cedar ridge and the groups that beat them above bell and Leander tho ? Is what I’m wondering. so much happened that was so unexpected . Oh and also round rock ??

[LostChoirGuy]

1. CTJ

2. Hebron

3. Carmel

4. Vandegrift

5. Avon

6. Broken Arrow

7. Flower Mound

8. Tarpon Springs

9. Ronald Reagan

10. Marcus

11. Blue Springs

12. Cedar Park

13. Wando

14. Castle

15. Homestead

16. The Woodlands

17. Keller

18. Hendrickson

19. Union

20. Leander

21. Cedar Ridge

22. O'Fallon

23. James Bowie

24. L.D. Bell

25. Ayala

26. Vista Ridge

27. Marian Catholic

28. Haltom

29. Owasso

30. Vista Murrieta

 

31. Round Rock

32. William Mason

33. Bellevue West

34. Park Vista

35. Fort Mill

36. Dobyns- Bennett

37. Pearland

38. Kennesaw Mountain

39. Dripping Springs

40. Center Grove

[Band band band 212]

1.Ctj

2. Hebron

3. Vandegrift

4. Avon

5. Carmel

6. Broken arrow

7. Tarpon

8. Flomo

9. Ronald Reagan

10. Marcus

11. Cedar park

12. Blue springs

13. Castle

14. Wando

15. Keller

16. The woodlands

17. Homestead

18. Union

19. Hendrickson

20. Leander

21. O’Fallon

22. Cedar ridge

23. James Bowie

24. Ayala

25. Haltom

26. Ld bell

27. Marian catholic

28. Owasso

29. Vista ridge

30 . Vista murrieta

[Bandwoww]

  On 11/6/2017 at 1:08 AM, Band band band 212 said:

Would that put cedar ridge and the groups that beat them above bell and Leander tho ? Is what I’m wondering. so much happened that was so unexpected . Oh and also round rock ??

I think that if one band has a decisive victory over another’s a competition like SA of Nats, the higher band shold be ranked higher. A lot of bands just ended thier season so there isn’t anything else to go off of just jet. For example, Keller should probably be ahead of Leander and The Woodlands because Keller was a pretty decent margin ahead of The Woodlands and almost 3 points ahead of Leander. Cedar Ridge should probably be above Haltom because no one knows how Haltom would’ve improved. And Cedar Ridge beating Leander shows thier improvement.

 

Past results and reputations can only last so long.

 

Also, some people argue that prelim results should be taken into great consideration. But when a competition spans multiple days with different judging captions, etc. it’s really hard to go with that. Especially since San Antonio prelims were very inconsistent even more so with the GE caption. Finals was very consistent.

[LostChoirGuy]

Part of it is the fact that results change from prelims to finals, too. While finals results should have more clout, I think its possible that certain bands are comparable such that one would beat the other 8/10 times but based on different judges opinions might lose out on the one time that matters.

[Mash]

  On 11/5/2017 at 3:51 PM, LeanderMomma said:

The scores were so tight at the bottom. It was crazy. I know the kids are disappointed but WOW...WHAT A LEVEL OF BRILLIANCE! This year the high level of competition was just outstanding in San Antonio. No shame!!

Agreed, no shame at all.  They represented very well.    This Vista Alumn parent is proud of all the bands.

[LeanderMomma]

  On 11/6/2017 at 3:18 AM, Mash said:

Agreed, no shame at all. They represented very well. This Vista Alumn parent is proud of all the bands.

Thank you. We Leander folks were really pulling for Vista to make it in to finals this year.

[Mash]

  On 11/6/2017 at 3:47 AM, LeanderMomma said:

Thank you. We Leander folks were really pulling for Vista to make it in to finals this year.

you're welcome.  There is always next year :-)  Exciting to see the 2 smallest 6A schools take on the giants again next year. :-)

[LostChoirGuy]

I totally forgot American Fork, UT. They should be at least in the next 10 if not in a top 30 ranking.