SA Finalist Shows Elimination Game

[Pasha78802]

Uncharted Waters +1

The 4th Dimension -1

 

Uncharted Waters 12

The 4th Dimension 29

On the Waterfront 46

Leonardo's Dream 41

Sculpt 38

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 36

Lost and Found 30

Loop 30

Pop! 22

[NotLeanderMomma]

Uncharted Waters -1

The 4th Dimension +1

 

Uncharted Waters 11

The 4th Dimension 30

On the Waterfront 46

Leonardo's Dream 41

Sculpt 38

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 36

Lost and Found 30

Loop 30

Pop! 22

 

Shhhhhhhhhh. It’s my secret identity. I’m NOT Leander Momma if anyone asks, okay?

[gregorydf01]

  On 8/4/2019 at 10:17 PM, NotLeanderMomma said:

Uncharted Waters -1

The 4th Dimension +1

 

Uncharted Waters 11

The 4th Dimension 30

On the Waterfront 46

Leonardo's Dream 41

Sculpt 38

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 36

Lost and Found 30

Loop 30

Pop! 22

 

Shhhhhhhhhh. It’s my secret identity. I’m NOT Leander Momma if anyone asks, okay?

     

[gregorydf01]

Uncharted Waters -1
The 4th Dimension +1

Uncharted Waters 10
The 4th Dimension 31
On the Waterfront 46
Leonardo's Dream 41
Sculpt 38
Polarity 33
Tremendous Sea of Love 36
Lost and Found 30
Loop 30
Pop! 22

[katytrailnorth]

Uncharted Waters +1

The 4th Dimension -1

 

Uncharted Waters 11

The 4th Dimension 30

On the Waterfront 46

Leonardo's Dream 41

Sculpt 38

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 36

Lost and Found 30

Loop 30

Pop! 22

[hippkerr]

Uncharted Waters +1

The 4th Dimension -1

 

Uncharted Waters 12

The 4th Dimension 29

On the Waterfront 46

Leonardo's Dream 41

Sculpt 38

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 36

Lost and Found 30

Loop 30

Pop! 22

[Grace]

Uncharted Waters -1

The 4th Dimension +1

 

Uncharted Waters 11

The 4th Dimension 30

On the Waterfront 46

Leonardo's Dream 41

Sculpt 38

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 36

Lost and Found 30

Loop 30

Pop! 22

[Garchomp]

Uncharted Waters -1
Lost and Found +1

Uncharted Waters 10
The 4th Dimension 30
On the Waterfront 46
Leonardo's Dream 41
Sculpt 38
Polarity 33
Tremendous Sea of Love 36
Lost and Found 31
Loop 30
Pop! 22 

[principalagent]

Polarity +

Tremendous Sea of Love -

 

Uncharted Waters 10

The 4th Dimension 30

On the Waterfront 46

Leonardo's Dream 41

Sculpt 38

Polarity 34

Tremendous Sea of Love 35

Lost and Found 31

Loop 30

Pop! 22

 

Eastern time zone

[Samuel Culper]

I went back to the beginning of this thread and looked at DOWNVOTES ONLY for the last 12 shows on the list in the game.  Total downvotes looked like this through post #867:

 

Leonardo's Dream    4

On the Waterfront    11

Loop    14

Tremendous Sea of Love    16

Polarity    18

Pop!    20

The 4th Dimension    24

Symphony of Silence    24

Change is the Only Constant    24

Sculpt    30

Uncharted Waters    82

Lost and Found    133

TOTAL    400

 

I'm sure my counts are not 100% accurate, but they are definitely close.

 

Items of note:

• WENDY had cast 17 downvotes among the 12 bands, 15 of those to Lost and Found, at the time she was asked to leave due to multiple voting "errors". The next day katytrailnorth joined the game and has since cast 35 votes against L&F
• The 35 by katytrailnorth against L&F are 2nd most downvotes for a single program to hipkerr's 42.  Also against L&F.  Notably, hipkerr and katytrailnorth both shifted to downvotes against The 4th Dimension in the last few days after both casting daily downvotes against L&F for the last month plus.
• There are 13 voters with at least 10 downvotes total to the final 12 programs.  Of those, 5 downvoted L&F most.  3 downvoted Uncharted Waters most.
• 61 of 63 downvotes by hipkerr are aimed at Leander ISD bands.  40 of 44 by katytrainorth are at Leander ISD.  (WENDY was 17 for 17).
• TWHSParent spreads the wealth like no other, casting at least one downvote against every one of the final 12, except On the Waterfront.  Of course.  

Yes, I only looked at downvotes and I understand that, to an extent, upvotes attract downvotes.  But overall, I think upvotes are a different dynamic, people naturally support the "home" team - al la TWHSParent.

 

I think the numbers do point to some axe grinding, which is why I left the game.  I don't get that kind of thinking.

 

Enjoy your day and Happy Marching Season!

[Garchomp]

Lost and Found +1
Uncharted Waters  -1

Uncharted Waters 9
The 4th Dimension 30
On the Waterfront 46
Leonardo's Dream 41
Sculpt 38
Polarity 34
Tremendous Sea of Love 35
Lost and Found 32
Loop 30
Pop! 22 

[FloMoParent]

Leonardo's Dream +

On the Waterfront -

 

Uncharted Waters 9
The 4th Dimension 30
On the Waterfront 45
Leonardo's Dream 42
Sculpt 38
Polarity 34
Tremendous Sea of Love 35
Lost and Found 32
Loop 30
Pop! 22 

[gregorydf01]

The 4th Dimension +1

Uncharted Waters -1

 

Uncharted Waters 8

The 4th Dimension 31

On the Waterfront 45

Leonardo's Dream 42

Sculpt 38

Polarity 34

Tremendous Sea of Love 35

Lost and Found 32

Loop 30

Pop! 22

[Bandnerd03]

Loop +1

Pop! -1

 

Uncharted Waters 8
The 4th Dimension 31
On the Waterfront 45
Leonardo's Dream 42
Sculpt 38
Polarity 34
Tremendous Sea of Love 35
Lost and Found 32
Loop 31
Pop! 21

[TWHSParent]

On the Waterfront +1

Tremendous Sea of Love -1

 

Uncharted Waters 8
The 4th Dimension 31
On the Waterfront 46
Leonardo's Dream 42
Sculpt 38
Polarity 34
Tremendous Sea of Love 34
Lost and Found 32
Loop 31
Pop! 21

[TWHSParent]

  On 8/5/2019 at 1:59 PM, Samuel Culper said:

I went back to the beginning of this thread and looked at DOWNVOTES ONLY for the last 12 shows on the list in the game.  Total downvotes looked like this through post #867:

 

Leonardo's Dream    4

On the Waterfront    11

Loop    14

Tremendous Sea of Love    16

Polarity    18

Pop!    20

The 4th Dimension    24

Symphony of Silence    24

Change is the Only Constant    24

Sculpt    30

Uncharted Waters    82

Lost and Found    133

TOTAL    400

 

I'm sure my counts are not 100% accurate, but they are definitely close.

 

Items of note:

• WENDY had cast 17 downvotes among the 12 bands, 15 of those to Lost and Found, at the time she was asked to leave due to multiple voting "errors". The next day katytrailnorth joined the game and has since cast 35 votes against L&F
• The 35 by katytrailnorth against L&F are 2nd most downvotes for a single program to hipkerr's 42.  Also against L&F.  Notably, hipkerr and katytrailnorth both shifted to downvotes against The 4th Dimension in the last few days after both casting daily downvotes against L&F for the last month plus.
• There are 13 voters with at least 10 downvotes total to the final 12 programs.  Of those, 5 downvoted L&F most.  3 downvoted Uncharted Waters most.
• 61 of 63 downvotes by hipkerr are aimed at Leander ISD bands.  40 of 44 by katytrainorth are at Leander ISD.  (WENDY was 17 for 17).
• TWHSParent spreads the wealth like no other, casting at least one downvote against every one of the final 12, except On the Waterfront.  Of course.  

Yes, I only looked at downvotes and I understand that, to an extent, upvotes attract downvotes.  But overall, I think upvotes are a different dynamic, people naturally support the "home" team - al la TWHSParent.

 

I think the numbers do point to some axe grinding, which is why I left the game.  I don't get that kind of thinking.

 

Enjoy your day and Happy Marching Season!

 

Axe grinding or reflecting a rivalry I think is fine on an individual level. When it spreads to spamming accounts and just being over the top juvenile about it is when it is a problem.

 

Interesting analysis. Did you actually go through manually or did you write a script to skim the messages?

[Samuel Culper]

I'd probably be more likely to write a movie script than something like that.

[Grace]

Lost and Found +1

Pop -1

 

Uncharted Waters 8
The 4th Dimension 31
On the Waterfront 46
Leonardo's Dream 42
Sculpt 38
Polarity 34
Tremendous Sea of Love 34
Lost and Found 32
Loop 31
Pop! 20

[katytrailnorth]

Uncharted Waters +1

On the Waterfront -1

 

Uncharted Waters 9

The 4th Dimension 31

On the Waterfront 45

Leonardo's Dream 42

Sculpt 38

Polarity 34

Tremendous Sea of Love 34

Lost and Found 32

Loop 31

Pop! 20

[CTJBandPops]

Sea of Love +1

Uncharted Waters -1

 

Uncharted Waters 8

The 4th Dimension 31

On the Waterfront 45

Leonardo's Dream 42

Sculpt 38

Polarity 34

Tremendous Sea of Love 35

Lost and Found 32

Loop 31

Pop! 20

[hippkerr]

Leonardo's Dream +1

Polarity -1

 

Uncharted Waters 8

The 4th Dimension 31

On the Waterfront 45

Leonardo's Dream 43

Sculpt 38

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 35

Lost and Found 32

Loop 31

Pop! 20

[Pasha78802]

Loop +1

Tremendous Sea of Love-1

 

Uncharted Waters 8

The 4th Dimension 31

On the Waterfront 45

Leonardo's Dream 43

Sculpt 38

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 34

Lost and Found 32

Loop 32

Pop! 20

[LeanderMomma]

Pop! -1

The 4th Dimension +1

 

Uncharted Waters 8

The 4th Dimension 32

On the Waterfront 45

Leonardo's Dream 43

Sculpt 38

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 34

Lost and Found 32

Loop 32

Pop! 19

[josephbandfan]

Loop +

Sea of Love -

 

Uncharted Waters 8
The 4th Dimension 32
On the Waterfront 45
Leonardo's Dream 43
Sculpt 38
Polarity 33
Tremendous Sea of Love 33
Lost and Found 32
Loop 33
Pop! 19 

[katytrailnorth]

Sculpt +1

Lost and Found-1

 

Uncharted Waters 8

The 4th Dimension 32

On the Waterfront 45

Leonardo's Dream 43

Sculpt 39

Polarity 33

Tremendous Sea of Love 33

Lost and Found 31

Loop 33

Pop! 19