Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Wow, VERY rough draws for Waxahachie, Marcus, and Round Rock going 1st, 2nd, and 4th. I remember in 2018 the Woodlands was the 1st band to perform and they nearly missed finals finishing 12th in prelims. Hopefully these groups are still able to perform at a high level.

Posted
  On 10/31/2021 at 5:00 PM, BandFan59 said:

Wow, VERY rough draws for Waxahachie, Marcus, and Round Rock going 1st, 2nd, and 4th. I remember in 2018 the Woodlands was the 1st band to perform and they nearly missed finals finishing 12th in prelims. Hopefully these groups are still able to perform at a high level.

Expand  

Great final block though- Flo Mo, Reagan and Vista Ridge all in a row. then Coppell and CTJ towards the end of that block

Posted

Top 12 predictions anyone?

I assume the "usual"

  1. Vandegrift
  2. Ronald Reagan
  3. Woodlands
  4. FloMo
  5. CT Johnson
  6. Hebron
  7. Marcus
  8. Vista Ridge
  9. Cedar Ridge
  10. Keller
  11. Westlake
  12. Coppell

 

Not in that order of course. Just the Top 12.  

But what do y'all think of the "breakout" bands from DFW:  Timber Creek and Southlake Carroll?   Carroll, especially has surprised us consistently in a good way. Timber Creek shocked me yesterday with a Top 5 finish. I had them at 7th. Good momentum for both these fantastic bands.

Posted
  On 10/31/2021 at 7:52 PM, HeartOfTexas said:

Top 12 predictions anyone?

I assume the "usual"

  1. Vandegrift
  2. Ronald Reagan
  3. Woodlands
  4. FloMo
  5. CT Johnson
  6. Hebron
  7. Marcus
  8. Vista Ridge
  9. Cedar Ridge
  10. Keller
  11. Westlake
  12. Coppell

 

Not in that order of course. Just the Top 12.  

But what do y'all think of the "breakout" bands from DFW:  Timber Creek and Southlake Carroll?   Carroll, especially has surprised us consistently in a good way. Timber Creek shocked me yesterday with a Top 5 finish. I had them at 7th. Good momentum for both these fantastic bands.

Expand  

Woodlands are not attending state.

Carroll and Timber creek I think will be close to the bubble of finals. Waxahachie will have their work cut out for them to make finals being first on.

 

Posted
  On 10/31/2021 at 7:52 PM, HeartOfTexas said:

Top 12 predictions anyone?

I assume the "usual"

  1. Vandegrift
  2. Ronald Reagan
  3. Woodlands
  4. FloMo
  5. CT Johnson
  6. Hebron
  7. Marcus
  8. Vista Ridge
  9. Cedar Ridge
  10. Keller
  11. Westlake
  12. Coppell

 

Not in that order of course. Just the Top 12.  

But what do y'all think of the "breakout" bands from DFW:  Timber Creek and Southlake Carroll?   Carroll, especially has surprised us consistently in a good way. Timber Creek shocked me yesterday with a Top 5 finish. I had them at 7th. Good momentum for both these fantastic bands.

Expand  

Woodlands will not be there - they opted out of state

Posted
  On 10/31/2021 at 7:52 PM, HeartOfTexas said:

Top 12 predictions anyone?

I assume the "usual"

  1. Vandegrift
  2. Ronald Reagan
  3. Woodlands
  4. FloMo
  5. CT Johnson
  6. Hebron
  7. Marcus
  8. Vista Ridge
  9. Cedar Ridge
  10. Keller
  11. Westlake
  12. Coppell

 

Not in that order of course. Just the Top 12.  

But what do y'all think of the "breakout" bands from DFW:  Timber Creek and Southlake Carroll?   Carroll, especially has surprised us consistently in a good way. Timber Creek shocked me yesterday with a Top 5 finish. I had them at 7th. Good momentum for both these fantastic bands.

Expand  

based on yesterdays results I would say that the the top half at SMBC will be - in no order

FloMo - bested Hebron

CTJ - bested Reagan

Vista - bested Vandy

Hebron

Reagan

Vandy

Posted

   Not a big fan of Hebron’s ensemble visual this year. As people have previously stated, they’re moving better and faster than ever, but it’s going to be a pain to get clean. Everything looks sort of blobby even when the feet are in time. Vandegrift on the other hand has a really great look IMO, just very challenging. I think they’re on schedule to peak precisely on finals night for state.

   Flower Mound also looks really good, their choreo is probably my favorite of any band this year. Music hasn’t cleaned up as fast as in previous years, but then again they’re on a different timetable. I’ve got them medaling at the very least here, regardless of who else is on the podium. I’d be kind of surprised to see this show win, but also not really. They are Flower Mound, after all.

   CTJ could absolutely take this thing, just depends on how much they can get done in the next week plus. They strike the balance between demand and showmanship really well. Vista Ridge I think has the furthest to go cleanliness wise, which is great for them because they have Grand ambitions. I don’t think it’ll be at the level of the other bands yet, but I’m not a judge or a band director. 

Posted

This is such an unusual year. So many of the pre-season "locks" like LD Bell, Duncanville etc. are not gonna be there. So many new names. Maybe this is the great reset and as King Arthur said to Sir Bedivere, "The old order changeth, yielding place to new."

Posted
  On 10/31/2021 at 5:00 PM, BandFan59 said:

Wow, VERY rough draws for Waxahachie, Marcus, and Round Rock going 1st, 2nd, and 4th. I remember in 2018 the Woodlands was the 1st band to perform and they nearly missed finals finishing 12th in prelims. Hopefully these groups are still able to perform at a high level.

Expand  

Can you explain why these are roughy draws? I’m obviously a novice.

Posted
  On 11/1/2021 at 3:27 AM, Cherish4 said:

Can you explain why these are roughy draws? I’m obviously a novice.

Expand  

For Waxahachie and Marcus - if they aren't getting to San Antonio the night before, thats a hellish logistical nightmare for the band. If the band truck is arriving at Alamodome at 6:30AM, subtract 5 (maybe more) hours from that for a reliable departure time from the Dallas area. Those kids will be exhausted before the contest even starts and thus won't be as well rested as some of their counterparts competing for finals.

More importantly, all 3 bands are strong contenders for finals (or even locks in Marcus' case). The bands need to perform strongly enough to remain in the forefront of the judges' minds for the rest of Prelims. A judge may be more conservative in scoring a band at the  very beginning of the day vs. later on - thus the bands who went earlier may get lower of a score than they would have if they had competed in a block closer to other potential finalist bands for a better judging comparison. 

 

Posted
  On 11/1/2021 at 4:18 AM, justabandkid94 said:

For Waxahachie and Marcus - if they aren't getting to San Antonio the night before, thats a hellish logistical nightmare for the band. If the band truck is arriving at Alamodome at 6:30AM, subtract 5 (maybe more) hours from that for a reliable departure time from the Dallas area. Those kids will be exhausted before the contest even starts and thus won't be as well rested as some of their counterparts competing for finals.

More importantly, all 3 bands are strong contenders for finals (or even locks in Marcus' case). The bands need to perform strongly enough to remain in the forefront of the judges' minds for the rest of Prelims. A judge may be more conservative in scoring a band at the  very beginning of the day vs. later on - thus the bands who went earlier may get lower of a score than they would have if they had competed in a block closer to other potential finalist bands for a better judging comparison. 

 

Expand  

Marcus always stays over from BOA to state. So they'll be okay. Besides, if anyone remembers Unwritten in 2019, they went first at like 7:30 at BOA SA on two hours sleep. They won the 4A prelims music caption--that performance was electrifying. There's just something about being the early band on the lot. 

Posted

I’m more worried for the bands that aren’t going to the San Antonio Super that also have an early draw time. They most certainly have to stay the night in San Antonio or risk a lot of things by trying to leave home immensely early.

Posted
  On 11/1/2021 at 12:59 PM, lost said:

I’m more worried for the bands that aren’t going to the San Antonio Super that also have an early draw time. They most certainly have to stay the night in San Antonio or risk a lot of things by trying to leave home immensely early.

Expand  

Exactly. I was more using Marcus and Waxahachie as an example for the general predicament of drawing early at a contest, since drawing time slots doesn't take into consideration the bands' physical distance from the Dome

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...