Texas Marching Classic 2022 (Oct 8th, 2022)

[peshbandkid]

  On 10/7/2022 at 8:47 PM, MikeKyu said:

This is a heavy contest. I can see things going a few ways in finals but this is my final guess:

1. Vandegrift H.S., TX  - They are going to win by 2.0+ points
2. Ronald Reagan H.S., TX  They are going to win visual pushing them above Cedar Park by the smallest of margins. 
3. Cedar Park H.S., TX  It hurts to put such a great conceived, played, and performed show in 3rd. I wouldn't be surprised to see this show in 2nd
4. Round Rock H.S., TX  They made strides and cleaned this show up considerably. After the last few years it feels oddly great to put the Dragons this high at this contest
5. Vista Ridge H.S., TX This show is cleaning up nicely but I think they will fall below the Dragon at this show. At the end of the year they will overcome Round Rock but not yet. 
6. Rouse H.S., TX  Not too much of a change the last few weeks. They have supposedly hit hard by COVID. 
7. Hendrickson H.S., TX  They are pushing hard to Grand Nats. 
8.Leander H.S., TX  Big improvement from BOA Austin. They aren't playing like Leander of near past but they are marching the show well.
9. Dripping Springs H.S., TX  Huge strides made in bringing this band back to prominence with a well thought out and played show.
These last 3 can go any way

10. John B. Alexander H.S., TX  My favorite dark horse in every contest  
11. Louis D. Brandeis H.S., TX  Up and coming band. They will learn a lot from this contest.
12. McNeil H.S., TX  They always seem to be on the bubble. This contest brings them to finals. 

Expand  

Exact same ordering as me, but a 2 point gap between Vandegrift and Reagan seems a little big. Then again, Cedar Ridge has more or less shown us early what the tiers could be

[MikeKyu]

  On 10/7/2022 at 9:06 PM, peshbandkid said:

Exact same ordering as me, but a 2 point gap between Vandegrift and Reagan seems a little big. Then again, Cedar Ridge has more or less shown us early what the tiers could be

Expand  

I believe the 2 point difference will all come from music at this contest. Vandy is clean clean clean right now. Reagan had a fair amount of dirt to clean up last weekend and some of those niggles will most likely remain. Visual performance is a dead heat between the top 3 right now. I put CP 3rd because I believe they are going to perform the 4th movement of the show. I saw video of it this morning. 

[natertater21000]

  On 10/7/2022 at 9:06 PM, peshbandkid said:

Exact same ordering as me, but a 2 point gap between Vandegrift and Reagan seems a little big. Then again, Cedar Ridge has more or less shown us early what the tiers could be

Expand  

It's worth noting that TMC is 60% performance captions and 40% GE where BOA is the opposite. Under that scoring criteria I can see a clean Vandy pulling off a two point lead.

[ohwell]

Doesn’t matter too much really, but Brandeis did finish ahead of Dripping Sorings at Austin. Clearly a lot can change in 2 weeks, but Brandeis could bump up to 9th or 10th

[lhbenlee]

Leander will be down 25 kids.  😔

[MikeKyu]

  On 10/7/2022 at 10:47 PM, lhbenlee said:

Leander will be down 25 kids.  😔

Expand  

I guess it's a good thing they no longer negatively judge on holes in shows then. 

In reality, that's terrible. Hoping for The Lions to recover quickly. 

 

[Samuel Culper]

Vista just performed pregame and I did not notice a significant number of holes. 🤞

[BandFan59]

  On 10/7/2022 at 10:47 PM, lhbenlee said:

Leander will be down 25 kids.  😔

Expand  

Good lord, that is insane. I remember when I was in high school it was normal to have maybe 2-4 holes at any given performance, but I couldn't imagine having a double digit amount of holes, much less 25.

[Band2021]

That is devastating I wish Leander the Best. This can be truly performance changing. They no longer score on missing marchers but we all know that visually it can have a high impact not to mention musically. 25! Wow 

[Oracle]

I don’t know but I presume:

1. Vandegrift (Visual, Auxiliary, General Effect)

2. Round Rock (Music)

3. Ronald Reagan

4. Cedar Park

5. Rouse

6. Vista Ridge

7. Robert E. Hendrickson

8. Dripping Springs

9. Winston Churchill

10. McNeil

11. Leander

12. Louis D. Brandeis

-

13. John B. Alexander

 

[Leander Band Fan Forever]

Hutto - This gives me a lot of Homestead 2021 vibes. A little rough on the music but the kids are having a blast! Visuals were quite good for being early season much better than how I’ve seen them previously! Fun band and they put out quite a sound.

Hendrickson - Amazing!! They’ve only gotten better since Austin. They need more control in their volume and more dynamic moments in their music but it’s not badly performed and it will be a nice 8th-16th placer at grand nationals.

Weiss - They sound a lot cleaner that at VRHS Marching Fest! They’re not bad. There’s something about the visual package that lacks the conituity to translate into high GE scores.

James Madison - Very strong! They will place higher than expected. It’s not a perfect show but they hit their moments when it’s expected. A similar vibe to what Leander is doing with a light themed show.

Leander - ….. They’ve been better. I don’t like the park and bark. The way they frame the field is a little puzzling and feels too enclosed. When a band like Highland Park closes the field like this it feels organic this feels confined. The visuals are not at the level they should be but they sound phenomenal when they play.

Tom C. Clark - Fun! Fun! Fun! This show is a lot of fun. It’s a lot like Vandegrift this year but a lot more compelling for the audience. It won’t make finals here but they could be in Area H finals in a few weeks. They’re better than I’ve seen them previously. 
 

[FaultLineBlues]

Lotta people forgetting to put their umbrellas down when the band is performing, currently watching through a sea of them. 

[MadisonBandMan1]

  On 10/8/2022 at 4:21 PM, Leander Band Fan Forever said:

Hutto - This gives me a lot of Homestead 2021 vibes. A little rough on the music but the kids are having a blast! Visuals were quite good for being early season much better than how I’ve seen them previously! Fun band and they put out quite a sound.

Hendrickson - Amazing!! They’ve only gotten better since Austin. They need more control in their volume and more dynamic moments in their music but it’s not badly performed and it will be a nice 8th-16th placer at grand nationals.

Weiss - They sound a lot cleaner that at VRHS Marching Fest! They’re not bad. There’s something about the visual package that lacks the conituity to translate into high GE scores.

James Madison - Very strong! They will place higher than expected. It’s not a perfect show but they hit their moments when it’s expected. A similar vibe to what Leander is doing with a light themed show.

Leander - ….. They’ve been better. I don’t like the park and bark. The way they frame the field is a little puzzling and feels too enclosed. When a band like Highland Park closes the field like this it feels organic this feels confined. The visuals are not at the level they should be but they sound phenomenal when they play.

Tom C. Clark - Fun! Fun! Fun! This show is a lot of fun. It’s a lot like Vandegrift this year but a lot more compelling for the audience. It won’t make finals here but they could be in Area H finals in a few weeks. They’re better than I’ve seen them previously. 
 

Expand  

Thanks for the kind words on my alumni program! For some reason they aren’t posting videos of their shows this year compared to usual so all I’ve seen are small clips here and there. Been wanting to see the show but can’t unfortunately. Sucks to be in Nebraska and not be able to just go to the show myself haha. 

[FaultLineBlues]

Although neither of them quite capture the song the way I'd like, I like Round Rock's composition of Adagio for Tron better than Vandys! The emphasis on low brass really mimics the synth of the original, really cool stuff. 

(although I do hope bands realize Daft Punk has a lot of great songs that aren't on the Tron soundtrack) 

 

Either way, great run from Round Rock! Happy to see them coming back as of late, the more RRISD bands doing well, the merrier! 

[FaultLineBlues]

Stony Point genuinely sounded the best I've heard them in a while! 

[Parkwoodmom]

  On 10/8/2022 at 4:30 PM, FaultLineBlues said:

Lotta people forgetting to put their umbrellas down when the band is performing, currently watching through a sea of them. 

Expand  

I was at a performance where the folks with an umbrella were asked to put their umbrella down when the show started, and they said No.  Maybe it should be included in the announcement about silencing cell phones and entering while a band is performing?   

[Hard Core Band Fan]

  On 10/8/2022 at 6:29 PM, OldViolet said:

I was at a performance where the folks with an umbrella were asked to put their umbrella down when the show started, and they said No.  Maybe it should be included in the announcement about silencing cell phones and entering while a band is performing?   

Expand  

Which is a real shame as the live experience is preferable to the online experience. But because so many people are rude, selfish, and inconsiderate these days, I no longer attend in person. I do miss the live experience, though, but not enough to endure all the negatives.

[MikeKyu]

You can always use the umbrella as a drum during performances. There is nothing saying you cannot, right? 

[SoundOff]

[SoundOff]

[lost]

Sandra Day O’Connor is shaping up for a really nice Area H finals spot.

[SoundOff]

JBA, Sandra Day O’Connor and Brandeis are all making it known that they are here! Amazing performances all around. 

[Mish]

Anyone has access to the prelim scoring results?

[BandFan59]

  On 10/9/2022 at 12:42 AM, Mish said:

Anyone has access to the prelim scoring results?

Expand  

Recaps should be released after finals

[ohwell]

How did the first half of finals look?